The decision to put a 548-acre business park in the southern portion of the city was stayed Tuesday night after opponents called for more information on the project.
Plans for the “innovative” Needham Ranch were put on hold by the Santa Clarita City Council after concerns were raised during four hours of public testimony about the removal of hundreds of oak trees in order to install 48 industrial lots on roughly 330 acres. The council gave city planners a laundry list of items to further research before it would consider voting on the project.
More than 230 acres will be donated to the city as permanent open space.
At issue is the removal of more than 1,600 oak trees and infringement on the Los Piñetos wildlife corridor, which is the main trail of animal migration between the San Gabriel Mountains and the Santa Susana Mountains.
Needham Ranch is located south of downtown Newhall, adjacent to Eternal Valley Cemetery and Memorial Park, paralleling San Fernando Road.
“We need to find a compromise with the incorporated thinking of all of these groups,” Councilwoman Laurene Weste said.
Several environmental groups rallied in the council chambers to voice their opposition to the project.
Paul Edelman, deputy director of the Santa Monica Mountain Conservancy, said the plan needs to be adjusted.
“They are forcing a land use that doesn’t fit the terrain,” Edelman said.
Instead, he said the lots in the southern portion of the project should be eliminated in order to save the corridor. Edelman told the council the project was a “ecological disaster” and shamed the city of ignoring its own self-imposed hillside ordinance. Project plans call for grading on hillside slopes greater than 10 percent.
Landowner Mark Gates dubbed the project innovative in design — and the Santa Clarita Planning Commission agreed with it unanimously OK’d the project in July — which allows grading on these slopes.
Gates has reworked the project several times and decreased the number of oaks removed on request of the commission earlier this year. He said the project, if approved, will be the keystone to revitalizing Newhall.
“We share your concern for saving the oaks,” Gates said.
Gates said more than 1,200 oaks will be planted throughout the project to make up for the removed trees.
The park is expected to generate roughly 8,000 jobs in the bio-tech, entertainment and aerospace industries that will contribute $5.7 million in retail sales annually.
Gates will also give $1.9 million to the city for improvements along San Fernando Road, the historic Pioneer Oil Refinery and the future Newhall Community Center. A chunk of the project rests in the Newhall Redevelopment district, which will receive approximately $140,000 a year.
Needham Ranch was once the target of a trash sorting facility, but Gates told the council that he has “made no plans or had any discussion of a possible (materials recovery facility) site” in the park.
Revitalization of Newhall was good news to many of the public speakers.
Resident Lyle Olsen said the park is just what that area of the city needs.
“Newhall needs to be redeveloped,” Olsen said. “And (Needham Ranch) project will do that.”
Jay Julien said the industrial park will help stave off the jobs to homes imbalance.
“Let’s face it, Newhall Land (and Farming Co,) has build this place, and now they have come,” Julien said.
David Hahn agreed.
“(Environmental issues) cannot be the overriding factor in this project,” Hahn said.
But not everyone put economics over ecology.
Twenty-year Newhall resident Chris Finn asked the council if residents have to comply with the oak tree ordinance, why should developers be held up to the same standard?
“It mocks the very thing it destroys,” Finn said. “This is a grotesque violation of the very spirit the city passed in its ordinance.”
David James of the Forest Preservation Society of Southern California said the city failed in its environmental review and proposed mitigations.
“You take all the development (benefits) and shirk all the impacts of your actions,” James said.
Attempting to find a happy medium, the council asked for more information and to have all interested parties meet to further discuss the project.
“Let get to work and save a few more oak trees,” Councilwoman Marsha McLean said.
City planners will address a handful of issues and report back to the council on Jan. 28.
