On the face of it, you might think it’s a contradiction in terms:
We’re screaming bloody murder over the possible destruction of a single oak tree that stands in the path of the widening of Pico Canyon Road.
Yet, just a few miles away, there is a commercial-industrial project that stands to destroy more than 1,600 oaks — and you won’t find us lying on the ground in front of the bulldozer.
How can that be?
The timing is ironic to say the least. Just as the debate rages over whether the 400-year-old Pico Canyon oak — which has been occupied the past couple of weeks by a tree-sitter hoping to save it — the City Council is faced with a decision on the proposed Needham Ranch project, a planned industrial center near Newhall.
We’ve editorialized strongly in favor of every attempt to preserve that Pico Canyon oak, which was here long before the town of Newhall was even a twinkle in its namesake’s eye. But we have issued no such battle cry in the case of Needham Ranch.
One oak tree vs. 1,661.
You couldn’t fault someone for asking, “What’s so special about that ONE oak tree?”
You also couldn’t fault someone for asking, “If you’re so hell-bent on trying to save that Pico oak, why isn’t the same battle being waged, 1,661 times over, against the Needham Ranch project?”
Fair questions.
And here, we hope, is a fair answer:
The oak in Pico Canyon is, first of all, four centuries old. That should count for something. It has withstood everything from animals marking territory to the suburbanization of the surrounding valley that only now seeks to threaten it.
It is also a visible landmark, an oak that can be seen simply by taking a drive up Pico — a rather pleasant sojourn for a Sunday morning, by the way. This is not an isolated tree on a remote piece of private, inaccessible property. And if Pico Canyon Road can be widened without taking out the tree, it would most certainly help preserve the diminishing aesthetics of our outlying areas.
There may be no saving it. But every option should be explored.
And, truth be told, we believe every reasonable option should be explored to save the 1,661 oaks that may be felled for the Needham Ranch industrial project. Considering the fact that the developer plans to save 10,000 oaks on the property — and also plans to set aside land for public open space, as well as a wildlife corridor — it seems fair to say that the developer has been diligent in trying to be cognizant of our valley’s special attachment to the mighty oak.
It may seem insensitive to boil down those oaks to numbers, but the batting average bears noting: The vast, vast majority of the Needham property’s oaks will be preserved. Further, some of the oaks to be destroyed are dead or have been damaged by fire — and only two are described as “heritage” oaks, those exceeding a specified size and age.
Obviously, significant, older heritage oaks should be preserved to the greatest extent possible. We sincerely hope the most cherished of our valley’s mighty old oaks can be saved from the bulldozers that continue to build homes, shopping centers and places of employment for our community’s burgeoning number of residents.
At the same time, we recognize that each set of circumstances must be evaluated on its own merits. All we ask is that our governments — our city and our county — conduct that evaluation with the right measures of sensitivity and pragmatism.
Snowflakes. Oak trees. Governmental dilemmas.
No two are the same.
