America is really living large these days. Currently in this country, more than 50 percent of all adults and 12.5 percent of all children ages 6-17 are seriously overweight.
Also significant is America’s desire to lose weight and a tendency for buying into fad diets that can prove ineffective, costly and even dangerous.
“Diet fads come and go,” said Registered Dietitian Heidi Holden. “What we need to teach people as far as losing weight and maintaining a healthy body weight is following good eating patterns that include all the food groups to maintain the body’s nutritional health.”
Despite a “growing” trend for “Big is Beautiful” advocacy, extra weight remains a super-sized public health concern — one that carries hefty health hazards. Added pounds boost one’s risk for developing medical conditions including elevated blood cholesterol and blood pressure, heart disease and stroke. Extra weight can also lead to diabetes, some forms of cancer, arthritis and other serious disorders.
An estimated 300,000 Americans died from obesity-related causes in 2000. The American Dietetic Association (ADA), the nation’s largest organization of food and nutrition professionals, projects obesity may pass tobacco as the leading cause of preventable deaths.
In addition to physical ailments, excess weight packs a psychological punch. Co-existing in a society where thinness and active lifestyles are prized, overweight people often suffer adverse emotional consequences including diminished self-esteem and lower quality of life.
Medical experts agree that the solution to this predicament lies in behavior modifications, i.e., weight reduction, learning healthy eating habits, and getting regular physical exercise.
These endeavors, however, cannot be achieved with the rapidity of a drive-thru diner. It takes knowledge, time and commitment.
Doctors advise that losing as low as five to 10 percent of one’s excess body weight is sufficient to reduce the risks for many chronic diseases and promoting psychological benefit.
Bad Fads
Many people who are overweight want to shed pounds but have no clue how to go about it. Like those who want a fast way to make a fast buck, these folks all-too-often take the bait for rapid weight loss plans and gimmicks. Americans shell out more than $30 billion each year to the weight-loss industry, much of it on quick-and-easy diet strategies that do more to drain the pocketbook than shrink the waistline.
Some of these diets can even be hazardous to your health.
The ADA reports that fad diets generally include common features: they promote quick weight loss; bill themselves as “cure-alls”; recommend or require supplements; specify what should be eaten at what time, with no exceptions; limit or avoid certain foods, and are short-term.
Knowing which diets to stay away from is important for achieving weight loss under optimally healthy conditions — and for keeping off the weight safely and permanently.
Some of the more popular fad diets:
n High-protein/ low-carbohydrate: Also known as the Atkins Diet, this is based on the idea that carbohydrates are bad for you and that many people are insulin-resistant, therefore they gain weight from eating them. Those following this high fat-high protein diet eat large amounts of protein (such as meat, bacon, etc.,) but are restricted when it comes to fruits, vegetables and grains.
Carbohydrate restriction and increased protein/fat consumption is anything but healthy, said Holden, a Saugus resident and nutrition lecturer/certified diabetes counselor.
“That is just hogwash,” she said of their safety and effectiveness. “The one thing that diet promotes heart and kidney disease.”
This is a bad weight loss method for several reasons, Holden said.
“It lacks vitamins and minerals that we need in our diet for good health as well as complex carbohydrates and fiber,” Holden said. “It can also cause us to increase our cholesterol and saturated fats in the diet and it can put a horrible strain on our liver and our kidneys.”
Such a diet can put people into ketosis, a biological process that results when glucose, as a source of energy, is not available from dietary carbohydrate and the body switches to primarily using fat. Symptoms of ketosis can include nausea, dehydration and weakness. Ketones are byproducts of fat metabolism, when there is not sufficient carbohydrate as a source of energy. For people who are restricting their intake of carbohydrates, ketone presence in the urine indicates achievement of a fat-burning phase that results in weight loss.
“Ketosis is a form of self poisoning...when our body uses ketones for energy instead of glucose it cannot work effectively,” she said. “With this diet water weight comes off first and then a huge amount of lean muscle mass, metabolically active tissue. It takes more calories to maintain it so you end up with a higher body fat proportion and it ultimately takes less calories to gain their weight back.”
High fat-low carbo diets have been around a while and are generally considered unsafe.
“We did this diet 20 years and found out how unhealthy it was then. It’s nothing new,” Holden said. “Atkins promotes ‘good food/bad food’ behavior but there is no such thing as bad food here. It is the amount you eat of it at one time.”
Dr. Terrence Cohen, a cardiologist, recalled a cardiac patient who went into acute renal (kidney) failure following an arteriogram (using x-ray dye) after which he had gone on the Atkins diet.
“I have no doubt that the diet was a major contributor,” Cohen said.
Cohen noted that once the diet was discontinued, the patient’s kidney status improved.
“I don’t know of any doctors recommending that kind of diet,” the doctor said.
n High-fiber, low-calorie: While these diets are designed to fill you up with fiber-rich foods (fiber cannot be digested, it does not have calories), they can cause gastrointestinal distress (bloating, cramping, constipation and dehydration) and deprive you of nutrition.
“With this diet the person can also be lacking in nutrient’s that our bodies need to work normally,” Holden said. “As with other fads diets, high fiber diets do not teach you healthy eating.”
n Liquid diets: These low calorie liquid meal replacements may be sold over the counter or by prescription and should not be used for long-term weight loss.
“They do not promote good health, but more than anything, they do not teach you good eating patterns...again, people will lose the weight but they will not learn how to eat properly or keep the weight off or use good nutrition,” Holden said.
n Fasting: This has been touted for years as a means of cleansing the body or as a good jump-start to a weight-loss program. In reality, fasting robs the body of nutrients and one ends up with low energy, weakness and lightheadedness — not weight loss.
When a person fasts, carbohydrates are not available for energy, thus, ketones can build up and stress the kidneys.
“This can be dangerous,” Holden said. “Fasting or an extremely low-calorie diet really deprives the body of its needed nutrients so it can function normally. One of the fasting diet (proponents) report that they cleanse the body and remove toxins but this is the farthest from the truth. It builds up ketones which is very damaging against our kidneys and can be very harmful to our health.”
n Sugar busters: This diet eliminates sugars and white breads. While it pushes whole grains it nonetheless cuts energy-packed foods that contain natural sugar. It also emphasizes protein and high fat consumption.
“This is not based on science, it’s just a low-calorie diet that promotes ‘bad food/good food’ thinking,” Holden said.
n Blood Type: This diet involves making food selections based on a person’s individual blood type.
“The blood type diet is the funniest of all to me,” Holden said. “You are supposed to eat according to when your blood type ‘evolved’ and what people were eating when it evolved. The problem is nobody knows when these blood types evolved. Only the author knows...these diets are all 1,200 calories!”
How to Choose to Lose
The American Dietetic Association recommends that to lose weight safely and keep it off one should go with a diet comprised of a wide selection of foods and is easy to live with.
Strive to eat a variety of foods. Vary food choices to ensure you get all the nutrients you need. Become knowledgeable of the United States Department of Agriculture’s Food Guide Pyramid, which contains all the building blocks of a healthful diet. There are five food groups with each group providing some, but not all, of the nutrients your body requires. Because foods contain different nutrients, there is no one food group more important than the other for good health, you need them all. The key messages of the Food Guide Pyramid are variety, balance and moderation. Maintaining a variety in foods also prevents boredom in eating and lessens chances for splurging and diet disasters.
It is wise to choose a diet with plenty of grain products, vegetables, and fruits. Not only are these foods low in fat, they provide roughage, or plant fiber, which can actually help speed up food passing through the colon.
“Fiber cleanses the bowel and increases transit time of food, this is very important,” said Lorrie Searcy, a registered dietitian with Facey Medical Group in Canyon Country. “The faster it gets transported out of the body, the less chance for toxins and possible carcinogens to linger in the bowel.”
It is heart-smart to select a diet low in cholesterol and saturated fat. (The latter are fats that come from animal and dairy sources and some plant oils, such as coconut and palm oils. These can increase your cholesterol level and should be avoided). You do need some fat for good health so don’t cut them out — but aim for 30 percent of your total calories. By staying away from foods due to their fat content you’re missing out on essential fatty acids and fat-soluble vitamins. (For a 2,000-calorie-a-day diet, hold the fat to less than 65 grams, recommends the ADA.)
Remember that “fat-free” or “low-fat” does not mean “calorie-free.” A superior way to control fat and lower risk for cardiovascular disease is to choose foods that contain healthy fats like olive or canola oils, and pay attention to portion sizes. Select lean meats, low-fat dairy and plant proteins for variety and nutrition. These modifications are vital: the American Heart Association reports that cardiovascular disease is America’s No. 1 killer, accounting for almost 50 percent of all deaths each year and affects nearly 14 million Americans.)
Certain cancers are linked to high animal fat consumption and obesity, Searcey said at a colorectal cancer awareness lecture.
“Eating more soybeans, legumes and lentils can help inhibit the growth of certain cancer cells,” said Searcey, who also provides nutrition counseling for seniors. “Such foods contain phytochemicals, thought to prevent carcinogenesis.”
People should especially limit their intake of red meat, which has been linked with colon cancer, she noted.
“Too much of anything is not good. Moderation is very important,” Searcey said.
Searcy added that people who consume lots of meats and cheeses tend not to eat a lot of fruits and vegetables.
Balance the food you eat with physical activity. Remember that regular, moderate exercise helps with weight loss and disease prevention. (Always check with your doctor before embarking on an exercise program.)
Because sugary foods and sweets are usually low in nutrients and supply empty calories, choose a diet low in sugars. Use less salt, too. (Salt is added to many foods during preparation or processing, so shake with caution.) If you consume alcoholic beverages, do so in moderation — beer, wine and spirits supply an abundance of calories, but little or no nutrients.
Cutting back on alcohol may even help reduce your chances for developing cancer, Searcey said.
“Some scientific studies have shown a link between alcohol and certain cancers,” Searcey said.
Also recommended: record what and how much you eat; identify eating behaviors you’d like to change; pay attention to times when you are eating and you aren’t hungry.
To lose pounds and keep them off it is recommended that one take it off slowly and reduce calorie intake to 1,200 to 1,500 calories/day (for most women) and 1,500 to 1,800 calories per day (for most men).
Don’t be in a hurry to slim down. The American Dietetic Association stresses that for new habits to take hold it takes about 90 days.
Guidance from medical professionals can be very helpful. To ensure health and safety, discuss weight loss methods with your physician.
Obtaining the qualified advice of a registered dietitian can also be a big plus in losing weight. Registered dietitians such as Holden and Searcey have a minimum of a bachelor’s degree, a year-long internship and have successfully passed a national examination.
Their assistance includes choosing sensible, workable eating plans, controlling food allergies or cholesterol and nutritional education.
Weighty Thoughts
“I have been on just about every fad diet known to man,” said Marlene Moeren-Kelly, (not her real name) a Newhall resident in her mid-40s. “I have eaten tons of grapefruit and cabbage, guzzled vinegar like it was ice water and worn Saran Wrap around my lower body for hours at a time. And I stayed fat.”
What finally worked for Moeren-Kelly, enabling her to lose the extra 40 pounds she had carried for decades, was simply watching her fat grams and caloric intake, eating well-balanced meals, getting regular exercise and increasing her understanding of nutrition.
“It turns out there is no magic bullet,” she said. “I only wish I had figured that out before. I could have saved thousands of dollars on diet fads and dashed hopes. I know what works now, though, and I plan to stay with it.”
