Being the chief executive of a city — any size — is a big job. That’s certainly true here in Santa Clarita, where the city manager oversees an operation consisting of approximately 300 employees and having a budget of more than $100 million.
It stands to reason that the compensation package for such a job should reflect the level of responsibility. But all too often it seems that those with their hands on the purse strings don’t maintain a tight enough grip.
Witness, for example, the contract of former City Manager George Caravalho:
If Caravalho had been fired by the City Council, he would have been entitled to as much as 36 months of severance pay under his contract with the city.
That’s not a typo. He could have committed an egregious, fire-able offense, he could have been terminated for cause, and he could have been able to continue living on your dime for three years.
Make that 5,262,496 of your dimes.
Further, Caravalho’s contract allowed him to quit his job at the city and get a cash payment for an ungodly amount of unused sick leave. When Caravalho quit his Santa Clarita job to become city manager of Riverside in May, he received, under the terms of his contract, more than $80,000 in compensation for unused sick leave.
It’s enough to make you wonder if Caravalho didn’t arrive in Santa Clarita a decade and a half ago, identify the city’s leaders as a drooling batch of clueless rubes and say to himself, “There’s a sucker born every day...”
Thankfully, our City Council this week demonstrated an ability to learn from the mistakes of the past.
The council tweaked the contract with newly appointed City Manager Ken Pulskamp before granting final approval, and the changes address some of the concerns that arose over Caravalho’s contract. The two key areas of change are severance and unused sick leave.
Like his predecessor, Pulskamp — the long-time assistant city manager who accompanied Caravalho here from Bakersfield — will receive a very attractive compensation package. He’ll make $175,000 per year, which seems a bit hefty, but so do a lot of other top-level City Hall salaries — and, as noted previously, it is a big job.
He’ll also have a city-leased car, and many of the other perks and benefits one would expect to accompany such a position.
He will not, however, have the opportunity to get fired and then keep feeding at the public trough for three years. The council cut the severance portion of the contract by more than half: Now, he’ll be entitled to a minimum of a year’s severance pay, with an 18-month cap.
To most people, that sounds pretty generous. And it is.
No one really anticipates that portion of the contract being exercised anyway — it seems unlikely that Pulskamp will find himself on the chopping block in the foreseeable future. But should circumstances change, it would be truly unfortunate to see a future city council hamstrung by the fact that it would cost more than a half-million dollars to make a change at the top of the city administration.
In addition, the council struck the compensation for unused sick leave — meaning Pulskamp won’t be in a position to quit and cash in $80,000 worth of sick time, like Caravalho did.
We’ve harshly criticized the City Council for its handling of the city manager hiring process, and we stand by our previous critiques, but we also believe credit should be given where it’s due. The council didn’t simply rubber-stamp a carbon copy of Caravalho’s excessive contract, and the changes that were made were fair and in the best interests of taxpayers.
It’s a big job, and the compensation should reflect that fact, but we don’t have to give away the store.
To their credit, our City Council members didn’t.
