The president of a statewide oak foundation and a certified arborist say the 400-year-old oak tree on Pico Canyon Road will die within 20 years if it is moved from its habitat.
The warning comes on the heels of Los Angeles County Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich’s decision Monday to move the 70-foot-tall tree as a solution to a nearly three week sit-in by activists. Antonovich and county planners decided to uproot and relocate the tree instead of realigning the road.
Janet Cobb, president of the Oakland-based California Oak Foundation, said the survival rate is the primary question for the tree that stands in the middle of a road-widening project near Stevenson Ranch.
“They can move anything,” Cobb said. “But I don’t recommend moving it. It might not be alive in 20 years or even five years.”
The county says Pico Canyon Road needs to be expanded from two lanes to four lanes to make way for future developments.
Rosi Dagit, a certified arborist and senior conservation biologist of the Resource Conservation District of the Santa Monica Mountains, said she plans to visit the ancient heritage oak today to inspect its status. Dagit said trees of similar size and scope have been successfully moved, but didn’t survive transplantation.
“Trees are not designed to move or be moved,” she said. “Moving an oak tree doesn’t save the tree. It just moves the tree and creates very expensive firewood after a long time of watching the tree decline.”
The county enlisted the help of the Calabasas-based Valley Crest Tree Co., the same company used to uproot oaks on The Newhall Land and Farming Co.’s Westridge project, to move the tree.
Valley Crest chief executive Stuart Sperber met with developer John Laing Homes and county public works officials to discuss transplant details. The results of the meeting were not known at presstime.
Antonovich spokesman Tony Bell said relocating the tree is the most equitable solution to solving the problem.
“We are optimistic the interested parties will back our proposal,” Bell said.
Dagit, who completed a 10-year study on moving oak trees in Calabasas last summer, said these trees can live for 800 to 1,000 years. Her study showed transplanted oak trees lose too much canopy and root mass to recover from the trauma.
She believes building the highway around the tree is less of a risk than transplantation.
“Long term, this tree has a better chance to survive if they build the road around it,” Dagit said.
John Quigley, who climbed the tree on Nov. 1, refuses to budge from his perch until a mutually acceptable agreement can be made without moving or cutting the oak, dubbed by children as “Old Glory.”
Paul Ash, president of the Stevenson Ranch Town Council, suggested a moratorium on the transplant and offered to mediate negotiations.
“A moratorium will provide for a cooling off period during which time it is anticipated that all parties will negotiate in good faith toward a resolution,” he said in a statement.
Cobb said there is no statewide policy to protect the trees and local ordinances are not strictly enforced. She said if people don’t look at the big picture, many oak trees in the state will fall victim to more housing development projects.
“There are thousands of oaks in California that are endangered from development projects,” she said. “This tree has become a symbol for thousands of oak trees in the state.”
