Tree relocation experts and environmentalists disagree on the future survival of the Pico Canyon oak tree as crews prepare to dig sometime next week.
Lee Newman, oak tree specialist and president of L. Newman Design Group, said even though there are no guarantees in life, the tree will survive the move.
“This will be a sensitive move with state-of-the-art technology,” Newman said.
But Lynne Plambeck, president of Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment, said tree sitter John Quigley will not come down without a $10 million performance bond to hold the relocation tree company responsible for the tree’s future. Plambeck suggested that if the tree lives beyond a contracted time limit, the money would subsidize a fund dedicated to the tree, which area children have named Old Glory.
“This is just another way to kill the tree,” Plambeck said. “Let them put their money where their mouth is. They need to give the community a guarantee.”
Valley Crest Tree Co. of San Fernando is part of a team to relocate the heritage oak tree about one-quarter mile northeast of where it has lived for the past 400 or so years. Newman and Pacific Horticulture Arborist Donald Rodrigues will oversee the project, which is expected to take up to five months.
At a press conference Thursday, tree relocation engineer Salvadore Ponce said his crew will start by measuring the tree and digging three feet down by hand. A backhoe will excavate around the tree and a box will be built around the roots. Cables will hold the branches together during the boxing. Ponce said after about 90 days, they will put a bottom in the box and move the tree with a hand-controlled dolly to an excavated hole with soil imported form the original habitat and a specially built drainage system.
The tree will be planted in a 20-acre park within the John Laing Homes development that has 120 existing oaks. About 170 additional oaks will be planted after the current relocation project is completed.
Los Angeles County Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich recommended the plan Monday, three weeks after Quigley, of Pacific Palisades, took up residence 50 feet above ground. Laing had tree service crewmen ready to cut down the tree on Nov. 14 to complete the widening of Pico Canyon Road to four lanes, per instructions from the county Department of Public Works. Instead, sheriff’s deputies were called when Quigley returned from a short break and were unable to stop the tree-sitter from climbing back onto his perch.
Paul Ash, president of the Stevenson Ranch Town Council, said a big concern is the increased traffic flow on Poe Parkway and Pico Canyon Road is needed to alleviate the congestion. Ash supports the county’s plan because it is a win-win compromise.
“We get to keep the tree in the center of our park,” said Ash. “It will become the heart of our community.”
Laing President Bill Rattazzi said he hopes Quigley moves out on his own.
“Quigley governs what he likes to do,” he said. “We will do what we need to do when the time comes.”
Bob Haueter, senior deputy to Antonovich, said Quigley should think about consequences for his personal safety and that of the tree.
“If his concern is for the tree, then he is going to come out of the tree,” said Haueter. “He will jeopardize his own safety when they move it.”
But Quigley said he is not concerned and vowed not to budge until the insurance policy is in place.
“I’m feeling good,” Quigley said. “I think we are moving in the right direction and it’s just a matter of time before we resolve this.”

