Kimberly Henderson said she will spend this Thanksgiving weekend without a home because she felt forced to resign as a registered nurse after Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital refused to accommodate her disability.
“I needed to file for unemployment,” Henderson said. “I have $3 in my checking account. I am literally losing everything. At the end of the week, I will be sleeping on the couch at my brother’s house.”
Henderson, who said she has 4 percent hearing in one ear and 25 to 40 percent in the other, said she resigned from Newhall Memorial on Nov. 19 after being on unpaid leave for several weeks while the hospital told her it was figuring out how to accommodate her need for a hearing-assist dog to help her perform her job duties, she said.
“How long does it take to find a position?” asked Henderson, who is in the process of filing for unemployment compensation. “It is a violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act — a failure to provide reasonable accommodations. They broke the law.”
Mark Puleo, director of human resources at Newhall Memorial, said since the hospital hadn’t officially accepted Henderson’s letter of resignation, he could not comment on her employment because he didn’t have her consent.
“We won’t accept her resignation until we have explored all the options here,” Puleo said. “We are in the process of doing a study to determine what areas of the hospital could accommodate a service dog.”
In the last six months, Puleo said Newhall Memorial has accommodated three other nurses with disabilities.
“The hospital always follows the letter and sprit of the law,” Puleo said.
He said it takes more time to find an accommodated position when service animals are involved.
“When you bring an animal into a hospital you always have health and safely issues,” Puleo said. “Animals are excluded where a sterile field is required.”
Lora Brugnaro, resource manager for the National Center on Workforce and Disability/Adult, said the ADA defines a reasonable accommodation as any accommodation that does not cause undue hardship to the employer.
Brugnaro, who did not comment specifically on Henderson’s claims, said the ADA requires the accommodation must be made in a timely manner, but does specify a specific time.
“Depending on your source, a timely manner is between 0 and 90 days,” Brugnaro said.
She said service dogs are an accommodation covered under the ADA, as long as the employee can show that having the service dog allows them to work more effectively or perform the duties of their job.
Brugnaro said a request for accommodations can be made through a supervisor or human resource person and can be verbal or written.
“My personal opinion is that it should always be done in writing, so that the employer can’t later deny that the request was made,” Brugnaro said.
Although the ADA does specify how much an employee should be paid for an accommodated position, Brugnaro said, the courts have ruled that if the position is modified to accommodate her disability, the pay should be equivalent. But if the position is changed altogether, the employee’s pay doesn’t have to be equivalent.
She recommends that if people have specific questions or concerns about their employment and the ADA, they should contact their local advocacy group.
Henderson, who suffers from progressive hearing loss that began to develop in 1995, started working as a registered nurse at Newhall Memorial on Feb. 25. Prior to that she was a nurse in Bakersfield.
In June, Henderson went to see her hearing doctor and discovered that with her hearing aids, her hearing had diminished. Her doctor recommended that she look into getting a hearing-assist dog. She said her doctor told her a dog would help her by signaling her when people are talking to her, and with everyday things such as bells, buzzers and timers.
“I don’t know why I am losing hearing,” Henderson said. “It might have been a side effect of the antibiotics I was administering to patients during my 10 years working in the ICU. Some people are more susceptible to the antibiotics than others.”
In July, Henderson applied for a hearing-assist dog and at the same time started looking for a job at Newhall Memorial to transfer to.
“I started looking at the job board for something that would accommodate my hearing loss,” Henderson said.
Soon after, Henderson was contacted and told that she was a potential match for a hearing-assist dog, and informed the hospital on Sept. 5 of the match. The next day she met with Puleo, the hospital human resources director, and told him she needed a position that would accommodate the dog. She said she was looking for a registered-nurse position that wasn’t direct patient care.
“I was told they were looking, but there was nothing currently available,” she said.
In October she went to San Francisco to get her dog. When she returned, she received a letter from the hospital telling her not to bring the dog to the hospital.
“We expect that you will remain in your current position and refrain from bringing a service dog to the hospital,” Puleo wrote in a letter to Henderson. “Obviously, until the evaluation process is complete, the presence of a service dog could present significant health and safety concerns.”
Henderson said she didn’t know what to do. She said she needs the dog in order to work and needs to work to keep the dog trained; it is required always to be with her.
“I need the dog to help me perform my job, but they say I can’t bring it to work,” she said. “It all comes down to, I was expendable because I had a disability. They should have said, ‘Once you get that dog, you can no longer work.’”
Henderson said she then sought legal advice after the hospital placed her on indefinite unpaid leave.
“I’m sorry I’m not perfect anymore, but it doesn’t make me any less of a human being,” Henderson said. “While they’ll all be enjoying the holidays this year, I won’t. I’ll be sleeping on my brother’s couch.”
