The debate over whether to remove a 400-year-old oak tree in Pico Canyon presumes one thing: that the road needs to be widened to four lanes in order to accommodate traffic from future housing construction.
Does it?
The Newhall Land and Farming Co. in a 1996 study said the widening of Pico Canyon Road was not necessary to accommodate traffic that would be generated by the developer’s planned 21,600-home Newhall Ranch project — and asked that the county amend its highway plan to “delete Pico Canyon Road as a major highway.”
“By deleting this roadway and emphasizing other east-west arterials (Valencia Boulevard, Magic Mountain Parkway, and state Route 126), the potential ... impacts on Pico Canyon are eliminated, yet adequate access capacity is still provided,” according to Newhall Land’s 1996 traffic study.
The Santa Monica Mountains Conservancy entered the fray on Nov. 8 when it sent a letter urging the county to protect the imperiled oak tree on the grounds that the 1996 study showed Pico Canyon Road could remain a two-lane road.
“The master planning for Newhall Ranch, and for the yet-to-be-approved Stevenson Ranch Phase 5 project, have identified no future need for a highway-standard road through Pico Canyon,” the conservancy said in its letter.
But the county’s public works department came to a different conclusion when it reviewed the development plans for the area.
In a Nov. 14 background report, county Public Works Director James Noyes states that Newhall Land’s 1996 study “not only failed to support the case for deletion of Pico Canyon Road, but rather supported the retention of Pico Canyon Road as a four-lane highway.”
The county found that Pico Canyon Road would see an average of 14,000 daily trips from Newhall Ranch, and another 6,000 from Phase 5 of Stevenson Ranch. The communities would use the road to access Interstate 5 and nearby commercial areas. Between 23,000 and 34,000 trips would be made daily on Pico Canyon Road west of its intersection with Stevenson Ranch Parkway, Noyes’ report states.
“Two traffic lanes will be required in each direction to accommodate this volume,” the report states. “We believe that a minimum of four through lanes ... will be needed on Pico Canyon Road to safely accommodate existing and future area traffic.”
But Newhall Land’s study indicated that the improvements to the Magic Mountain Parkway off-ramp would mitigate traffic “without the need for Pico Canyon Road.”
Newhall Land spokeswoman Marlee Lauffer said the finding in her company’s traffic analysis to keep Pico Canyon as a two-lane road was appropriate.
Phone calls to Lennar Corp., master developer of Stevenson Ranch, were not returned Thursday.
In its letter, the Santa Monica Mountains Conservancy said that on the basis of the “well-defined lack of future need to build Pico Canyon Road at highway standards, in combination with the regionally significant scenic, recreational ... and ecological resources,” the county Public Works Department “(should) rapidly initiate the process to complete the downgrading of Pico Canyon Road from a highway to a collector street on the county’s master plan of highways.”
It was more than 14 years ago, on Aug. 17, 1988, when the county’s Regional Planning Commission approved permits for the construction of Pico Canyon Road as a major highway, and for the removal of oak trees. The road project was subsequently revised and Pico was redesigned to save 14 oaks, but the removal of the tree that has been at the center of the recent controversy was deemed unavoidable, Noyes’ report states.
