If it has done nothing else before ending its 400-year life, oak tree No. 419 has provided a window into our community.
Through that window we have seen the type of short-sighted planning that has left a legacy of insufficient roads, overcrowded schools and denuded hillsides.
Through that window we have seen the passion that, thankfully, rallies around contentious local political issues, the high level of caring that, regardless of one’s position on a particular debate, is admirable.
And through that window we have seen our own hypocrisy as a community.
We have a county government and a developer who said they would work together to plan the widening of Pico Canyon Road in such a way as to save the oak. They didn’t.
We have residents who have been in this community for — what? Five minutes? And they wrap themselves in the leaves of Old Glory, playing the role of environmentalist, arguing for the oak’s life to be spared — then going home to their brand new half-million-dollar tract homes on hillsides where the graves of oak trees are still fresh. We may agree with them on the issue, but the irony is undeniable.
We have a Santa Clarita City Council that purports to advocate environmentally sensitive planning, yet only managed a 3-2 vote in favor of asking the county to save the oak.
And we have members of the Stevenson Ranch Town Council, essentially telling the Santa Clarita council to “butt out,” expressing dismay that the city would be so bold as to voice an opinion on a matter outside its borders.
Funny thing. They don’t seem to mind blurring the borders when it comes to taking advantage of the city’s infrastructure and park programs.
Whatever. All ramifications of the “gimme” culture aside, the oak where professional tree-sitter John Quigley has made his home since Nov. 1 is a technicolor illustration of what can happen when people in power don’t think ahead.
In the chess game that is development vs. environmentalism and anti-growth zealotry, the county and developer are guilty of failing to think one move ahead, much less two.
Here at The Signal, we typically are on opposite sides from the environmentalists as we advocate well-planned growth — but this isn’t it. We find ourselves in a somewhat unfamiliar position, sympathizing with those who have drawn a line in the dirt surrounding oak No. 419.
This controversy has been a public-relations bonanza for the anti-growth crowd, and not without merit. The widening of Pico Canyon Road may not even be necessary — the developers of the biggest housing developments west of Interstate 5 have said, at various points over the years, that they could do without it.
But even if you presume that it’s necessary, the county and John Laing Homes — the developer responsible for this particular segment of Pico — could have avoided this mess. The county could have called for a full environmental impact report on the Pico widening/extension. It’s a study that should still be ordered — and could bring the “Old Glory” crisis at least to a temporary end.
And John Laing Homes could have done what it led local environmentalists to believe it would do a couple of years ago: Design the widening in such a way as to protect the tree. That supposed promise, it turns out, was nothing more than carefully crafted language designed to leave enough wiggle room for the builder, but not enough for the tree. Homes were built so close to the oak that the tree’s wiggle room was obliterated.
Where does all of this leave us?
In terms of the tree, it leaves us with a stalemate that has no end in sight. John Quigley is living up there. Until he is removed by force or a resolution is reached that prompts him to climb down voluntarily, the stalemate will continue.
In terms of our own sense of self as a community, it has shown us our best — and our worst.
