A graceful exit.
Sometimes, in politics as in theater, that’s the best possible outcome for which to hope.
And so we are seeing with the issue of the now-famous oak tree in Pico Canyon, the one whose age is estimated by some to be 400 years and whose remaining life expectancy is the approximate equivalent to the amount of time it takes to ensure the tree is no longer inhabited by humans.
As most local residents know, that has been the focal point of a heated political debate since Nov. 1, when Pacific Palisades resident John Quigley climbed the tree and took up residence in its limbs in order to prevent it from being destroyed at the hands of developer John Laing Homes.
The tree, you see, stands in the way of the planned widening of Pico Canyon Road, which is perceived by Los Angeles County officials as being necessary to accommodate future growth in the area. John Laing Homes is a relatively small player in the grand scheme of impending development, but happens to be the builder responsible for that particular stretch of road.
The situation at one time or another over the past couple of years has been mishandled by virtually every interested entity: The developer, the county government and the environmental community that has in the past two months turned the plight of “Old Glory” into a public relations bonanza.
Now, what they all really need is a way out.
Quigley has announced that he will get his: He said this week that he plans to climb down from Old Glory in January to return to his regular job with the Malibu Foundation for Environmental Education, and the local environmentalists who recruited him to climb the tree in the first place will send substitute tree sitters in Quigley’s place.
It’s not difficult to imagine the ordeal continuing well past Quigley’s departure, but we can’t help wondering if the great tree debate will have the same allure for the masses as time is allowed to pass and the identity of the tree sitter changes with regularity.
Regardless, the time has come for all involved to put the debate to an end.
The Los Angeles County government seemingly had such an opportunity in the past couple of weeks as the developer and an environmentalist-commissioned designer each put forth different concepts on how Pico Canyon Road could be widened without removing the tree.
However, this week — on Christmas Eve — the county dropped a Charlie Brown-sized lump of coal into Old Glory’s stocking, rejecting the alternative road plans and sticking to its assertion that the tree has got to go.
Even if you agree with the county’s position, you have to admit the timing stinks.
If the county ultimately sticks to its guns, Old Glory is as good as firewood. The county says the tree can be moved — something John Laing Homes has agreed to do, at a cost of several hundred thousand dollars. But the environmentalists’ arborists say the move, in all likelihood, will be as deadly to the tree as a chainsaw would be.
In past weeks, we have taken the county and the developer to task for their respective failures to protect this particular tree. We stand by those assertions. With better planning, the new residential community that abuts Pico Canyon Road could have allowed for the road to be widened without killing the tree where John Quigley, for now, is making his home.
We have also called for a complete environmental impact report on the entire widening of Pico Canyon Road. We stand by that, too: Old Glory certainly is not the last issue that should be considered in Pico Canyon.
The environmental community desperately wants to save this particular tree, but perhaps there are ways to achieve a victory — or at least a partial one — even if it means Old Glory becomes a fallen soldier in their battle. The developer has agreed to spend a great deal of money to move the tree, but one can’t help wondering whether that money might better be spent on something else that might help promote the concept of a “green” Santa Clarita Valley.
At the moment, it seems all sides need to find a way to extricate themselves from the situation without completely losing face.
They need a graceful exit.
