A Los Angeles County Superior Court judge ruled Friday that the Castaic Lake Water Agency cannot legally act as both a water wholesaler and retailer — and the ruling could mean a split of CLWA’s retail water division into a separate company.
Judge David Yaffe’s decision in the case, which returned from an appellate court last year, mandates that CLWA cannot own and operate the Santa Clarita Water Co., which it purchased in 1999 for $63 million.
In his decision, Yaffe found that the companies merged when CLWA purchased SCWC, and in doing so SCWC “does not continue to exist as a separate corporate entity.”
Court documents stated that his findings were based on a number of factors, including that the SCWC board of directors members are also board members of CLWA; that SCWC’s customers are billed by the CLWA; that payments are made to the agency; and that SCWC’s financial responsibilities, including payroll and water costs, are handled by CLWA, among other factors.
The documents stated that CLWA “does not deny the foregoing facts, but contends that Assembly Bill 134, effective Jan. 1, 2002, permits the agency to sell water at retail even though it does not have a written contract with a water retailer that is not its alter ego.”
AB 134, authored by San Diego-area Republican Assemblyman David Kelley on behalf of CLWA, amends the state water code to give CLWA the special authority to operate Santa Clarita Water Co.
Yaffe’s findings follow an earlier court decision on an appeal by the plaintiffs in the case, activists Lynne Plambeck, Jill Klajic and two others.
At that time, the appellate judges determined that a “wholesaler-only” agency, such as CLWA, may operate at retail only if it has a valid, ongoing contract with an entirely separate company that is regulated by the Public Utilities Commission.
As soon as CLWA purchased Santa Clarita Water, the company became a part of CLWA, and the PUC historically does not regulate public agencies.
“Assembly Bill 134 amends section 12944.7 of the Water Code to permit the agency to sell water directly to the ultimate water consumer within the agency territory, only if it exercises its right to sell water directly to consumers pursuant to a written contract with a public entity water purveyor that serves water at retail or to a water corporation that is subject to regulation by the Public Utilities Commission and serves water at retail,” Yaffe’s decision stated.
Yaffe’s decision states that as of Sept. 30, CLWA must show that SCWC is operated as a separate entity.
CLWA officials released a statement stating that “the agency will be reviewing the decision and assessing its full implications. An appeal of the decision is one of the options that will be explored.”
The statement also said that “in his ruling, the judge ignored the intent of the Legislature in enacting AB 134, which was to allow the agency to directly operate at retail within a small geographic area, and not through an intermediary.”
Plambeck said that separation between the two will give the public more involvement in the process.
“I am happy that the tax rate payers of Santa Clarita Water will get better oversight,” she said.
