A federal bankruptcy court judge denied Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital’s request to have its largest single creditor dismissed as a creditor on a missed deadline technicality Wednesday.
Bankruptcy Judge Arthur Greenwald ruled that Facey Medical Group’s missed deadline to substantiate its claim against Newhall Memorial, which filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection Nov. 26, was not reason enough to have the medical group removed as a creditor.
“He decided not to throw out our claim on the technicality,” said Bill Gil, chairman of the Newhall Memorial’s creditors committee and chief executive of Facey. “He’s not saying our claim is right or wrong. He’s saying he’s not throwing away our claim on that technicality.”
GIl said since Facey was in ongoing discussions with Newhall Memorial in regards to a deadline extension on substantiating its claim, he felt the hospital was being deceptive in filing for the dismissal.
“This was a cheap shot by them to get off on a technicality,” Gil said. “It was done behind our back. We were in conversation with the debtors counsel about a deadline extension when they filed the motion.”
Newhall Memorial spokeswoman Andie Bogdan, who did not respond to the judge’s ruling, said Facey has been consistently trying to delay the bankruptcy process while the hospital has worked to move forward.
“They defaulted twice on their deadline to argue our objections to their claim,” Bogdan said.
Facey’s claim against Newhall Memorial is $1.5 million if the hospital paid everyone it owed money to as part of a contract with Facey and $4.2 million if the hospital doesn’t pay everyone it owes under the terms of the contract.
Newhall Memorial has filed a motion to invalidate the contract because Facey’s former president was a member of the hospital’s board of directors when the contract with Facey was signed and that the conflict of interest was not reported to the board of directors.
On Jan. 27, Gil said Facey will argue that the contract is valid because Newhall Memorial’s former president and chief financial officer, who signed the contract, were fully aware of the conflict of interest.
