Regardless of what you think should happen with the tree and the road — need we explain which ones we’re talking about? — there appears to be no good reason for the road to be cordoned off.
Ever since John Quigley launched his protest two and a half months ago, developer John Laing Homes has steadily widened the perimeter around the old oak tree with chain-link fencing to keep people away.
At first there was no fence and people could walk right up to — and climb — the tree. Then, Laing erected a fence around the base of the tree, roughly under its canopy, and hired security guards to restrict access. The fence became an impromptu wailing wall where wishful school children dangled drawings and protesters placed placards calling on the county and the builder to spare the tree.
Last week Laing removed the signs, ordered people back — leaving Quigley in his perch until Friday — and erected more fencing, this time blocking off Pico Canyon Road to all vehicular and pedestrian traffic. That’s how the situation remains today.
The problem is twofold. First, the blockage is an inconvenience for nearby Stevenson Ranch residents who are cut off from one of their two access roads in and out of their neighborhood.
Second and potentially more egregious, there’s a state park at the end of Pico Canyon Road, and the public can’t get to it.
The state park is Mentryville, the 19th-century ghost town where California’s first productive oil well was drilled. The 850-acre Mentryville property was acquired in the mid-1990s by the Santa Monica Mountains Conservancy, which maintains it and opens it daily to the public (with volunteers leading guided tours of the old buildings every other weekend).
And now, people can’t get to it. At least, they can’t get to it without the hassle of being interrogated by Laing’s private security guards and negotiating an alternate route through the neighborhood — if the guards let them.
That’s wrong.
And now we learn it might not even be legal. It turns out the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors decided way back in 1890 that “the Newhall and Pico Cañon Road” — which extended all the way from downtown Newhall to Mentryville at the time — is a “public highway 40 feet in width.”
There has been a presumption that the eastern stretch of Pico Canyon Road hadn’t yet been dedicated to the county, so Laing could do whatever it wanted to it. Now it seems that presumption might be wrong. According to the Conservancy’s grant deed, the supervisors’ “public highway” ruling was current in 1995, when the Conservancy acquired the Mentryville property.
This discovery opens up a whole host of questions.
For starters, under what conditions can a developer close a “public highway,” even temporarily?
Why is the county allowing a developer to restrict access to a state park?
Why isn’t the county ordering Laing to do what Caltrans does when that agency widens a public road from two lanes to four — namely, keeping at least one lane open and stationing people with signs at each end, so as not to impede public access?
The backhoes that have been digging around the tree, preparing to move it, haven’t needed to use the two existing lanes. The bulldozers and cement trucks that have been working on the road haven’t needed both lanes. Even if and when the tree is moved down the street, the road will need to be closed only a relatively short time to accommodate the movers.
Keeping protesters as far away as possible from the tree isn’t a good enough reason to close a road, especially when there’s a state park at the other end. If the county has accepted Pico as a public highway — in 1890, no less — then the road should be open to the public.
