A Los Angeles Superior Court judge denied environmentalists’ request Tuesday for a temporary restraining order to stop the movement of Old Glory.
Judge John P. Shook said developer John Laing Homes did everything in its power to help save the Pico Canyon oak tree.
“I’m satisfied that the owners went above and beyond their call of duty to preserve and protect the tree,” Shook said.
And in a statement that stunned the activists in the courtroom, the judge said the 21,000-home Newhall Ranch development — which may use Pico Canyon as an access route — will provide jobs and revenue for the community.
“I term it as progress,” Shook said.
Anthony D. Zinnanti, who represented tree sitter John Quigley and the Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment (SCOPE) in Tuesday’s hearing, said he was shocked at the judge’s comments.
“I am surprised that the judge brought into consideration evidence that was clearly not before the courts,” Zinnanti said at a press conference held immediately after the decision. “Specifically the talk about the jobs, the housing, and taxes, and the county being depleted of its tax base.”
Quigley, who had been living in the tree since Nov. 1, but was evicted on Friday, said he was also disturbed by the judge’s statement.
“I was extremely alarmed at his comments about Newhall Ranch,” he said. “I thought it was inappropriate for the judge to be making that kind of comment in this case. They were clearly not before him. To me, it calls into question the integrity of the process.”
During the hearing, the judge listened to environmentalists and developers as to what options are best for the tree’s survival, as well as other issues, such as the projected widening of Pico Canyon Road, where the tree stands, and costs incurred throughout the battle to the developer and taxpayer.
“What we’re seeking now is a dialogue,” Quigley told the judge. “The community is not convinced that the county has given proof that (Pico Canyon) road can’t be built around tree. By you taking action today, the ultimate winner will be the community, by an airing of all views.”
Attorneys for the developer and its parent company, Laing/Brookfield Venture, LLC, argued that if the temporary restraining order was granted, their client and the taxpayers would feel the effect.
“It is costing my client $2,500 a day to have ’round-the-clock security,” Edward Galloway said. “If there is a 10-month delay, it will cost my client at least $750,000.”
Galloway added that the taxpayers are already paying for city and county resources utilized in Friday night’s eviction of Quigley.
“The Sheriff’s Department, the Fire Department, the California Highway Patrol – they were all out there Friday night,” he said. “It’s not just my client that’s paying for their security, but it’s also costing the taxpayers. There are sheriff’s deputies out there now to make sure nothing goes wrong around the tree.”
After hearing the arguments, Shook made his decision and said the temporary restraining order requested by Quigley and SCOPE was “most respectfully denied.”
Although Shook’s decision was a major blow to environmentalists’ efforts to save the tree, Quigley said the fight is not over.
“It’s one day in court,” he said. “We will go back. We will assess the situation and we will continue on. The spirit of Old Glory lives.”
