A former Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital registered nurse has filed a lawsuit against the hospital seeking more than $750,000 in damages, alleging the hospital refused to accommodate her disability, created a hostile work environment, discriminated against her and harassed her.
The lawsuit was filed Friday in Los Angeles Superior Court by Kimberly Henderson, who said she has 4 percent hearing in one ear and 25 to 40 percent in the other. Henderson alleges she was forced to resign from Newhall Memorial on Nov. 19 after the hospital deliberately failed and refused to accommodate her need for a hearing-assist dog to help her perform her job duties as a nurse.
“Filing this lawsuit was a difficult thing to do,” said Henderson, who says she lost her home and car after resigning from Newhall Memorial. “As nurses we don’t do that, but it came to a point where what they were doing was wrong. It was morally, ethically and lawfully wrong. I went from an independent middle-class life to having my brother support me and my 2-year-old child.”
Newhall Memorial spokeswoman Andie Bogdan said that since the hospital had yet to be served with the lawsuit, she couldn’t comment on it.
In November, Mark Puleo, director of human resources at Newhall Memorial, said since the hospital hadn’t officially accepted Henderson’s letter of resignation, he could not comment on her employment because he didn’t have her consent.
“We won’t accept her resignation until we have explored all the options here,” Puleo said. “We are in the process of doing a study to determine what areas of the hospital could accommodate a service dog.”
In 2002, Puleo said Newhall Memorial has accommodated three other nurses with disabilities.
“The hospital always follows the letter and sprit of the law,” Puleo said.
He said it takes more time to find an accommodated position when service animals are involved.
“When you bring an animal into a hospital you always have health and safety issues,” Puleo said. “Animals are excluded where a sterile field is required.”
Henderson’s lawsuit alleges that, “Throughout her employment with the hospital, (Henderson) performed the duties of her work assignments in a capable and competent manner, and has been so recognized by management and supervisory personnel.
“However, as her employment continued, and she had made a request to the hospital for a reasonable accommodation of her disability, (Henderson) was required to work in an increasingly hostile work environment, was deprived of essential resources necessary to the proper performance of her work responsibilities, and became subjected to a continuing series of unlawful discriminatory, harassing, and retaliatory adverse actions,” the lawsuit alleges.
Henderson, who suffers from progressive hearing loss that began to develop in 1995, started working as a registered nurse at Newhall Memorial on Feb. 25, 2002. Before that she was a nurse in Bakersfield.
In June, Henderson went to see her hearing doctor and discovered that, even with her hearing aids, her hearing had diminished. Her doctor recommended that she look into getting a hearing-assist dog. She said her doctor told her a dog would help her by signaling her when people are talking to her, and with everyday things such as bells, buzzers and timers.
In July, Henderson applied for a hearing-assist dog and at the same time started looking for a different job at Newhall Memorial. “I started looking at the job board for something that would accommodate my hearing loss,” Henderson said.
Soon after, Henderson was contacted and told that she was a potential match for a hearing-assist dog, and she informed the hospital on Sept. 5 of the match. The next day she met with Puleo and told him she needed a position that would accommodate the dog. She said she was looking for a registered-nurse position that didn’t involve direct patient care.
In October she went to San Francisco to get her dog. When she returned, she received a letter from the hospital telling her not to bring the dog to the hospital.
Henderson said she didn’t know what to do. She said she needs the dog in order to work and needs to work to keep the dog trained, because the dog is required always to be with her.
Henderson said she then sought legal advice and resigned on Nov. 19 after the hospital placed her on indefinite unpaid leave.
“They decimated my life,” Henderson said. “My 2-year-old daughter and I are now homeless. Getting this dog should have given my independence back, but they were making me choose between my independence and the hospital. For all of their lip service, they never had any intentions of accommodating me.”
