Words can be peculiar things, especially when used in combination by one party and reinterpreted in a different environment, or at a different time, by another party. Take the second amendment to the Constitution, for instance.
It says, “A well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed.”
Those words are clear to just about anyone who reads them. Funny thing is, some will insist that they clearly say one thing, while others will insist they clearly say something almost completely opposite.
Closer to home, there was a fire last weekend near The Master’s College in Placerita Canyon. We carried a news story the next day about the fire, which came dangerously close to the dormitories. The story included a little bit of background about some of the other troubles the college has experienced lately, such as disagreements with neighboring residents about plans for a large chapel and a sewer system.
We got calls. It seems some of our audience read something between the lines that we didn’t intend to put there. Some folks thought the news story was trying to imply that the neighbors might have tried to torch the college.
Nothing could be further from the truth. But we can’t really fault people for their interpretation. Maybe the story could have been worded differently, or maybe it would have been prudent to omit the background information. We never imagined it could be misunderstood.
It was probably with equal consternation that the officials from the Castaic Lake Water Agency learned of a Superior Court judge’s ruling Friday.
Here was a judge who, in a downtown Los Angeles courtroom, read the same new legislation many people in Santa Clarita have been following for almost a year.
The legislation is known as Assembly Bill 134, and whether you like the CLWA, dislike it or don’t care about it, if you’ve followed the story, chances are you believed AB 134 cleared up the agency’s authority to sell water through its retail division, the Santa Clarita Water Co.
The bill grew out of a lawsuit filed in 1999 when CLWA bought the formerly independent water purveyor for $63 million. A group of CLWA critics believed the prior law, then in effect, prohibited a “wholesaler-only” agency — CLWA — from selling water at retail, so they tried to block the sale.
While the lawsuit was tied up in court, CLWA convinced legislators to change the state’s water law — probably because they believed their case was thin — but in any event they were successful in changing the law, via AB 134, to give CLWA clear authority to operate a retail water division.
At least, that’s what everyone thought AB 134 did.
AB 134 says, among other things: “This bill would authorize the agency to exercise retail water authority within a specified area.”
CLWA officials thought it was pretty clear. We editorialized under the assumption that it was pretty clear. Even the CLWA critics who are suing the agency never suggested to our reporters that they thought otherwise about the meaning of AB 134.
So everyone was surprised when Judge David Yaffe ruled Friday that AB 134 doesn’t allow CLWA to sell water at retail the way it’s doing it. In fact, Yaffe said, in essence, that AB 134 places even greater restrictions on the water agency.
There’s little doubt that the agency will appeal the decision. After all, the intent of the Legislature was to give CLWA the authority to sell water to Santa Clarita Water Co. customers.
Or was it? Is that what the men and women in Sacramento intended to do when they approved AB 134?
Words can be peculiar things, especially when used in combination by one party and reinterpreted in a different environment, or at a different time, by another party. Take AB 134, for instance.
