A federal bankruptcy court judge has given Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital two alternatives for resolving its motion to have its largest single creditor dismissed as a creditor.
Bankruptcy Judge Arthur Greenwald ruled Monday that Newhall Memorial’s motion to invalidate its former contract with Facey Medical Group will have to be settled through either an arbitration proceeding or litigation in March.
Roger Seaver — president of Newhall Memorial, which filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection Nov. 26, 2001 — said he hasn’t decided which to choose, but for the purpose of expediency, he said the hospital might prefer arbitration.
Newhall Memorial’s motion asserts that its former contract with Facey should be invalidated because it was a violation of state law for Facey’s former president, who was also a member of the hospital’s board of directors, to sign the health contract without reporting his conflict of interest and actions to the hospital’s board of directors.
Bill Gil, chairman of Newhall Memorial’s creditors committee and chief executive of Facey Medical Group, also supports arbitration. Gil said Facey will argue that the contract is valid because Newhall Memorial’s former executive officers, who signed the contract, were fully aware of the conflict of interest.
“Our position is we are a creditor no different than anyone else,” Gil said. “We don’t understand or agree with Facey being singled out and dined what we are owed.”
Facey’s claim against Newhall Memorial amounts to $1.5 million if the hospital has paid everyone it owed as part of a contract with Facey and $4.2 million if the hospital hasn’t paid everyone it owes under the terms of the contract.
“Henry Mayo says the contract is null and void,” Gil said. “But if the contract isn’t, the hospital is still disputing the amount they owe us.”
Gil said whether arbitration or litigation is chosen to resolve the motion, Facey wants the whole issue to be decided.
“If it is valid, then we want to know how much owe us,” Gil said. “We are regular creditor and we want to be recognized that way.”
Gil said attorney’s for Facey and Newhall Memorial will meet soon to decide on arbitration or litigation.
