Lord, guard and guide the men who fly
Through the great spaces in the sky.
Be with them always in the air,
In darkening storms or sunlight fair;
Oh, hear us when we lift our prayer,
For those in peril in the air!
— Mary C. D. Hamilton (1915)
I watched the videotape over and over as the once proud Columbia, at one time the sentinel of America’s new era in spaceflight, disintegrated into what appeared to be a collection of shooting stars streaking across the wide blue expanse of a Texas morning sky.
It was immediately obvious that, with the destruction of their craft, the seven astronauts aboard were also lost.
I grieve for them and their families, even though I personally did not know them.
As the seven stages of grief play out... (shock, denial, bargaining, fear, anger, despair and acceptance) I find myself stuck in anger and despair.
As inevitable as it will be to lose brave men and women in the conquest of space, I wonder if this loss was merely an accident — or, something far worse, negligence.
I despair that the average American seems more concerned about whom the next “Survivor” or “American Idol” will be rather than the state of the space program.
At one time our astronauts WERE our “American Idols” — our gladiators in the public relations war with the Soviet Union.
Now our space shuttle fleet is aging, with no grand vision or replacement technology in sight. Our gladiators have been replaced by scientists and a fickle public that would rather watch “Celebrity Justice” than a live shuttle launch.
I despair at an apathetic public more and more enamored of the superficial and the trivial — than the substance and glory of exploration and discovery.
Yet I am more angry at NASA and our public policy makers. I am angry at the examples of neglect and inattention in the space program:
n The Rand Corp. reported a reduction in shuttle maintenance staff from 3,000 to 1,800 workers during the years 1995-1999.
n The current shuttle fleet has now been in service twice as long as its builders expected – or planned.
n In the last decade inflation has shrunk the NASA budget by 40 percent.
n Computer chips used on the shuttle — once state-of-the-art — are generations out of date.
n The shuttle design is nearly 40 years old.
There was no contingency for the shuttle astronauts to be able to exit the Columbia and perform a visual inspection of the vehicle. Why? When the protective foam peeled off the fuel tank at launch and struck the left wing, perhaps a little look-see should have been considered — despite the official NASA line that it is impossible for the astronauts to exit over the side of the payload bay for a peek.
Granted, an in-space repair of the protective tiles is most likely out of the question — you can’t grab a can of Henry roof cement and slap a roof tile on the wing — however, with the might, muscle and brain of the United States there should be some kind emergency plan in place.
I know I’ve seen too many “space-rescue” movies, but I don’t understand why a “rescue shuttle” or docking with the International Space Station would have been unfeasible, if the proper equipment had been installed on the Columbia in the first place. Not planning for this kind of horrific outcome, one that could possibly be averted, is unfathomable to my way of thinking.
I watched the NASA officials declare “nothing could be done” — an almost unspoken “we really didn’t WANT to know if the foam had caused damage” and am horrified that the “can-do” American spirit has been replaced by weasel words and “head in the sand” thinking.
I think if these folks had been at the helm of NASA when Apollo 13 went sour, we would be mourning four major space disasters, not just three.
There’s something else about this disaster that winds its way into the hoary, eons-old, superstitious portion of my brain. I champion the pursuit of science — yet, in a part of my primitive brain left over from the ancient DNA of cave dwellers and hunter-gathers lost in the dim mists of history — I know there are many things that can’t be explained by science and the “rational” mind.
This was the 113th trip in space for a shuttle. Thirteen was not a lucky number for Apollo 13 — the return of that ill-fated expedition to the safety of Earth was nothing short of a miracle.
Why are the three greatest disasters in the United States space program clustered within a one-week span? Certainly years apart, but there are 365 days in a year — doesn’t the law of averages dictate that such a coincidence is, well, creepy?
Was it another “coincidence” that this shuttle also carried the first Israeli astronaut? While not as heralded as Christa McAuliffe, the first “teacher” on a space flight who died when Challenger exploded, the “first” connection echoes in the mind.
In addition, the “experience” level of the two crews, Challenger and Columbia, were almost identical, with four of the Challenger crew having one space flight under their belts, versus three of Columbia’s crew with one flight each. All the others on board both ships were rookies.
If the numbers reported by The Associated Press are correct, Columbia, which launched from Cape Canaveral in Florida on Jan.16, was only 16 minutes from a safe landing when contact was lost. Is this the devil’s numerology?
Does any of this strange speculation mean anything other than weird coincidence? Probably not — but in trying to make sense of the incomprehensible, the human mind is capable of wonderfully intricate gymnastics.
Fate, fortune, karma, grand design, simple human error or gross negligence? There is no consolation for the loss of our nation’s bravest explorers, those who sought to lead the way to a better future for our children and grandchildren.
Jan. 27, 1967, Apollo 1: Ed White, Gus Grissom, Roger Chaffee.
Jan. 28, 1986, Challenger: Francis R. Scobee, Michael J. Smith, Judith A. Resnik, Ellison S. Onizuka, Ronald E. McNair, Gregory B. Jarvis and Christa McAuliffe.
Feb. 1, 2003, Columbia: Rick Husband, Michael Anderson, David Brown, Kalpana Chawla, Laurel Clark, William McCool and Ilan Ramon.
Michele E. Buttelman is the features editor of The Signal. She can be reached by e-mail at [email protected].
