Environmentalists suffered a major blow Tuesday when a Kern County Superior Court judge upheld the Castaic Lake Water Agency’s 2000 Urban Water Management Plan.
The UWMP is a state-required assessment of water availability designed to help area water purveyors meet the valley’s water needs.
The suit, filed by the Friends of the Santa Clara River, Ventura County and the Sierra Club, accused the agency of overstating the availability of water for the yet-unapproved Newhall Ranch project, and questioned the document’s characterization of groundwater reliability amid reports of perchlorate contamination.
Attorneys for the plaintiffs were unavailable for comment. However, Dr. Gordon LaBedz, conservation chair of the Los Angeles and Orange County Sierra Club, said the decision was a major disappointment.
“Water doesn’t exist in the (Newhall Ranch) development,” LaBedz said. “The water is polluted. It’s dangerous and it can’t be counted as drinkable water.”
But according to a CLWA statement, Judge Richard J. Oberholzer considered and rejected multiple objections to the plan, including population and water demand projections. The statement also said the court determined that substantial evidence and expert testimony supported the statements in the UWMP.
“We were proven to be right,” said CLWA President Peter Kavounas. “We had staff work very diligently on this and deliberated it. It is safe to say that the agency takes pride in the plan and that we all take our job very seriously.”
Kavounas said the judge’s ruling validated the agency’s work.
“In the end it was really good for us,” Kavounas said. “We agreed that we had done a good job. The agency and its staff did a great job with the Urban Water Management Plan. We were surprised someone would contest the agency’s plans. We feel this is a good service for rate payers and tax payers in this valley.”
Officials for CLWA, one of 29 state water wholesalers in California, said it was the first time a state water wholesaler’s UWMP had been assailed in a lawsuit. The Urban Water Management Planning Act became law in 1983.
The Sierra Club’s LaBedz said it was a certainty that Oberholzer’s decision will be challenged.
“This law had never been tested,” he said. “They broke the law. “The judge made a bad decision. It has to be appealed. Unfortunately, environmental law is routinely overlooked and ignored. So we definitely have to appeal.”
LaBedz also said he and other environmentalists want to see the Santa Clara River protected from development.
“We are concerned about Newhall Ranch going forward,” he added. “We are against urban sprawl. We would really like to preserve the Santa Clara River for future generations.”
