ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Oak tree ruling shows flaw in justice system

What’s wrong with the legal justice system? This week, what’s wrong with it is Judge John P. Shook of the Los Angeles County Superior Court.

When environmental groups and the county of Ventura sued the county of Los Angeles a couple of years ago, alleging Los Angeles County supervisors violated their own policies when they approved The Newhall Land and Farming Co.’s 21,600-home Newhall Ranch project, the case was moved to the neutral territory of a Kern County courtroom.

It’s called a “change in venue,” and it’s a routine action that’s taken when there is reason to believe that one side or the other in a legal dispute can’t get a fair hearing. Judges and juries are supposed to consider only the testimony that is presented in court, so high-profile cases that generate a lot of press locally are typically moved out of town to places where the judge and jury are less likely to be influenced by extemporaneous information that might be factually inaccurate or legally irrelevant and thus prejudicial.

In the matter of Ventura County vs. Los Angeles County, there was the perception that a judge in Ventura or Los Angeles couldn’t be impartial so the case was moved to Bakersfield — where a neutral judge ultimately agreed with some of Ventura’s complaints and threw out others.

The upshot was that Newhall Land had to go back to the drawing board and re-work some of its plans, particularly with regard to water supply.

The redrawn plans will head back to the Los Angeles County supervisors soon for approval, and then the Bakersfield judge will have to say everything’s OK before construction can begin.

Tuesday’s downtown Los Angeles courtroom drama in what was supposed to be a separate matter proved that moving the Newhall Ranch case to Kern County was a good idea.

On Tuesday, Judge John P. Shook denied a motion by environmentalists to temporarily stop the removal of the infamous Pico Canyon oak tree — long enough for both sides to appear in court on a lawsuit that had already been filed a few weeks ago. The environmentalists believed the tree shouldn’t come out now if there’s a chance a court could decide later that it shouldn’t come out at all — and once it’s gone, it’s gone.

Shook sided with the builder, John Laing Homes, which argued that it has all the proper approvals from the county of Los Angeles, and it’s losing money every day the tree is still standing there.

If it had been left at that, fine. The oak tree would be gone and many members of the community would be upset, but the judge would have done his job and the tree huggers — sitters — would have had their day in court.

But Shook didn’t leave it at that. Oh, no. In making his decision, he went beyond the bounds of his authority and considered information that wasn’t presented in court. He can’t do that.

Specifically, Shook based his ruling in part on the fact that a widened Pico Canyon Road is needed for the Newhall Ranch project — the yet-unapproved Newhall Ranch project — and that Newhall Ranch, he said, will provide jobs for roofers, framers and the like.

“I call it progress,” he said.

Be that as it may, we call his inventive decision-making a blunder at best, and impropriety at worst.

Never mind, for now, that Newhall Land says it doesn’t need a four-lane Pico Canyon Road for Newhall Ranch. The simpler fact is, since no attorney in Shook’s courtroom presented evidence about job creation in Newhall Ranch, Shook can’t take it into consideration.

Doubly egregious is that the “facts” Shook took it upon himself to consider aren’t “facts” at all, because legally, they don’t become facts until the supervisors approve Newhall Ranch and the Bakersfield judge signs off.

Shook’s decision Tuesday should be appealed, and Shook should be reprimanded — because judges who don’t follow the rules undermine the public’s confidence in the system.

← Back to 2003

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-vs:1777.
System
ViewStory pages (/News/ViewStory.asp)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 667 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
viewstory:font_body
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • text:valley_names [4 distinct/25 mentions: Newhall, Pico Canyon, Newhall Land, Newhall Ranch]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 3, national 0