Was author John Steinbeck a socialist? President Roosevelt a dictator? What put people back to work in the early part of the 20th century — New Deal programs or World War II?
These and other questions were thrown at dozens of witnesses at Saugus High School on Thursday as students conducted a mock trial as part of a team project for American Literature and U.S. History.
Dressing as characters from Steinbeck’s novel “Grapes of Wrath,” and historical figures from the Depression era, students in Steve Jolliffe’s English class and Jim Klipfel’s history class took on the prosecution and defense as the New Deal went on trial.
It would be up to Klipfel to decide who presented the best case.
The defense blamed President Herbert Hoover for the Depression while praising the work of Roosevelt. A student portraying Steinbeck said he believed Roosevelt’s New Deal attempted to help the “small man.”
Hoover was grilled mercilessly by the defense as he touted the benefits of his rugged individualism policy which allowed the rich to get richer, they said.
The prosecution shot back by questioning a pregnant midwestern farm wife and telling her she “put her head in the sand” as the economy crumbled around her.
Jolliffe said the two teams consisted of 42 juniors who researched their roles after reading “Grapes of Wrath” and studying the Great Depression.
“We did this a couple of years ago with Huck Finn,” Jolliffe said. “The students held a mock trial to decide whether to ban the book.”
The focus of this year’s mock trial was migrant farm workers, and Jolliffe admitted the historical figures included were a bit of a stretch.
“We have Cesar Chavez, but many people don’t know his father was a farmer who lost his land during the Depression,” Jolliffe said.
Students, waiting to be called to the witness stand, said they were learning a lot from both of their teachers.
“It’s a lot more interesting to learn history this way,” said Charlana Firestone, 16, dressed as the head of the Farmer’s Union. “I think the trial is going well, although the prosecution is prone to give speeches, and not asking the right questions.”
Lead prosecutor Ashlee Anderson was frustrated and she vented to her fellow attorneys — Kristin Anthony and Bethany Hale.
“Our fellow classmates do not know their history,” she said.
In the end, though, it was the defense who proved its case.
“The prosecution failed to prove that the New Deal was unprecedented violation of the constitution and thus the defense was victorious,” Jolliffe said.
