Former tree sitter John Quigley has filed a motion to disqualify a Los Angeles Superior Court judge from the ongoing court battle to save the oak tree known as “Old Glory.”
Quigley’s move to disqualify Judge John P. Shook stemmed from a Jan. 14 hearing in which Quigley and the Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment sought a temporary restraining order to halt the removal of the Pico Canyon oak tree. Quigley alleges Shook issued an adverse ruling based not on the merits of the request, but on Shook’s own beliefs about growth.
Shook was quoted in court documents as saying, “(O)nce these structures are constructed, built, it is going to add terrific revenues in the terms of real property taxation to the depleted coffers in the California treasury. So I think it is a positive move and I term it as progress.”
Quigley, who was evicted from the controversial tree on Jan. 10, said the statements constitute a reason for Shook to step aside.
“I think the motion speaks for itself,” he said. “I felt the comments made at the hearing were out of line and were completely biased. Those statements he made were clearly outside of the court’s (authority) and it sounded like more of a political speech. It’s in the best interest for him to step aside.”
In the meantime, attorneys for both parties — the environmentalists and developer John Laing Homes — must agree on another judge in the county to hear the motion. If there is no agreement, the matter is transferred to a court outside of Los Angeles County.
Shook could not be reached for comment.
Bill Rattazzi, president of John Laing Homes, said he was unaware of the motion and would not comment on it.
Shook has 10 days to respond to the motion, but Quigley said he feels certain the court will grant his request.
“It will be interesting to see if he (Shook) steps aside,” Quigley said. “We’re trying to ensure fairness, because clearly fairness was called into question. We are confident that fairness will prevail.”
