First it was a mace-induced stampede in Chicago, then a botched pyrotechnics blaze in Rhode Island. Along with the hundreds of families now ravaged by these recent tragedies, some 492 souls in the “other world” are surely shaking their ethereal heads.
After all, it was their untimely deaths 60 years ago in a fiery Boston nightclub that helped change awareness and laws governing safety in such establishments — policies that apparently were not being upheld on these evenings.
For those unaware of the Cocoanut Grove nightclub fire, let’s go back in time ...
It was Nov. 28, 1942. World War II was kicking into gear. Some 1,000 occupants were crammed inside the swanky 600-person club. There, in its Melody Lounge and dining room, they were having a carefree, romantic night out. Dancing, laughing, many were preparing to go overseas on military duty. It was to be a night to remember.
To this day there’s conjecture over the exact cause of the momentous, 15-minute inferno. A lit match used by a 16-year-old busboy while changing a light bulb has long been considered the probable cause. Whatever the source, the Grove went up like dry brush, and understandably so with its many flammable decorations — colorful paper-and-tinsel palm trees, and fabric wallpaper.
Once the fire began, frenzied men and women clawed to escape. But for many, trampling, crush injuries and asphyxiation were their fates. Getting out was nearly impossible, what with a rear exit welded shut, and the two inwardly opening, revolving front doors completely blocked.
At that main entrance, lifeless bodies were ultimately found in charred layers, stacked four and five deep. Authorities estimated that at least 300 of those killed could have been saved had the club’s doors swung the other way. Among victims who died was Buck Jones, a well-known actor in Western movies.
Two major, nearby hospitals received a staggering 414 burn and smoke-inhalation victims. Boston City Hospital reportedly received one patient every 11 seconds, the greatest influx of patients to any civilian hospital in history.
Just as tragedies often lead to new preventative strategies, this occurrence prompted major changes in fire safety and public building regulations. Look around today at places of public assemblage and you’ll see evidence. Things like emergency lighting and occupant-capacity placards, exit lights — these were required as a result of the Cocoanut Grove fire. Additionally, life-saving legislation was passed that required doors in public buildings to open outwardly, rather than inwardly.
Also gleaned from the ruins were new standards for disaster planning, triage and modern trauma care. The advanced treatment of burn injuries and smoke inhalation actually began after this calamity. Massachusetts General Hospital, which received 114 victims, became the first burn unit in the U.S.
You’d think with such awareness and safeguards in place, these new nightclub deaths would not have occurred. But they did — and no doubt there will be repeats of the same, unless everyone acts more responsibly. That includes conscionable business and building owners, managers, bouncers, performers, booking agents, business attorneys, building inspectors and all related personnel.
Patrons also have to share some accountability. As entertainment “consumers” you need to know who and what you are dealing with when you step out on the town. If you go clubbing, carefully examine the place and its inherent conditions. Is it a sound, well-maintained, licensed establishment, with easy-to-see, working exits? Does it have proper lighting, operational sprinklers and fire extinguishers? Is it headed by responsible, law-abiding proprietors and security workers?
Or, is it some wild hangout that houses overcrowded soirees? Is it a venue where drugs are used? Where people drink excessively? Do fights tend to break out? Are these clubs the sites of fly-by-night flyer parties? Do the performers or guests bring in fireworks or other incendiary devices?
According to crowd management experts, there are certain things people should know to improve their odds for surviving a fiasco such as those we have just witnessed. Included in the tips below are some of their recommendations.
n Dress: Refrain from wearing accessories like long jewelry, flowing scarves, spikes, chains and dangly purses — things that can get tangled and cause injuries. Wear comfortable shoes and make you’re your laces are tied. That way, if there is a stampede, you won’t trip and fall. Should you lose your shoes in a crush or stampede, don’t stop to get them. Getting knocked down is the last thing you want ... it could also be the last thing that ever happens to you alive.
n Upon entering: Always find out where the exits are and make sure they are operational. If the event-room-hall is oversold, get your money back and leave (and notify the fire department).
n Getting out: Look around for cues that something is askew. If possible, don’t wait for all hell to break loose before leaving. Get out. Fleeing by running or moving down stairs or to exits is extremely dangerous, especially where the momentum of the crowd can topple you and trample you to death. Being first in line or right up against a stage or barricade can prove lethal. If something bad happens, people in back will have no idea what’s taking place up front — and that is precisely where crowd pressure builds fastest. Because a crowd surge generates an incredible amount of energy, once it starts it’s like a speeding train and it can knock you down. If you find yourself in the middle of this wave, do not stand still or sit down, for this is how you can get crushed. Instead, keep legs moving in the direction of the crowd, and try to get to the outside where the flow is weaker.
Try your best not to fall, but if you do, get up fast. If you can’t, get someone to pull you back up. If you cannot stand back up, keep moving by inching toward the direction of the crowd. (Always go with a friend; then, if chaos arises you both stand a better chance of having someone to help you out or pull you back up if you fall.) If you can’t get up, curl into a ball and cover your head (and maybe say a prayer).
To help tighten controls on clubs and prevent future disasters, I suggest county officials consider routine, thorough inspections with visible grading placards in all establishment windows, like those that rate our restaurants for food safety. Just as such scrutiny helps curb food-borne illness, this measure could be a valuable tool for the business owner and public.
Hopefully with renewed awareness, nightclub attendees will stand a better chance at surviving their night out — as well they should. In 2003 just as in 1942, club-goers just want to have a little fun. They flock to these places looking for excitement, not carnage.
No one should have to leave a joint with a toe tag as his eternal souvenir.
Diana Sevanian is a Signal staff writer. Her commentary appears on Saturdays. You may reach her via e-mail at [email protected].
