If I were related to any of the people who died or were injured in the recent Johnston, R.I., nightclub inferno, I’d be burning mad. Their loved ones’ loss of life and ensuing suffering evidently resulted every bit as much from the inappropriate use of indoor pyrotechnics as from the club’s use of cheap, highly flammable polyurethane foam as sound-proofing material.
Actually, there’s also a whole lotta guilt to go around.
Shame on you, Station club owners Jeffrey and Michael Derderian, for letting greed win over human safety. By saving money through purchasing this combustible, inferior grade of foam, you contributed to your club becoming a time bomb for catastrophe.
Here you bought these low-cost materials and are now the ones crying that you did not know they were dangerous. Spare me! As businessmen and conscious humans, where were your smarts and concerns for public welfare when you failed to get a written guarantee of the foam’s fire safety?
With all the hot lights and high wattage used in your wooden establishment, you knew you had fire concerns, even without Great White’s indoor pyro display. (By the way, knowing the group used fireworks on-stage elsewhere — just two days before their appearance at your club — why did you not forbid them from doing so?)
You cost-conscious bro’s cut corners elsewhere, too. In March 2000, when you were about to buy the club, you made promises at City Council meetings that you would have a firefighter and police officer inside (and a second firefighter in the parking lot) for crowd control at your all major events. According to your local fire officials, no fire detail was present on Feb. 20, the night of the blaze.
Another mind-blower: According to a major Boston newspaper, Jeffrey Derderian, a former television reporter for Channel 7 in Boston, had even addressed the dangers of polyurethane in a consumer-conscious broadcast in 2001. Derderian had reported on the potential dangers of the foam in a segment on mattresses and fire safety, saying fire experts called the foam “solid gasoline that can cause a smoldering mattress to burst into flames.”
Something reeks here, and it’s more than flesh and ashes — it’s hypocrisy.
Shame on you, Aram DerManouelian, president of American Foam Corp., for providing the foam — primarily made for stuffing cushions and for padding shipping boxes — but specifically cut to proportions for this establishment. Not only did your crew knowingly sell these materials to a nightclub; you also apparently did not provide a written or verbal warning, apprising them of the foam’s potential fire danger. Unless you are brain-dead, you must have had some idea what this product was destined for.
DerManouelian has been quoted as saying the foam is indeed flammable, but that it’s up to customers to know their needs. He also said that if they had asked, he would have told them about the foam’s inherent dangers.
Excuse me? Whatever happened to taking the high road and providing consumer safety information to one’s clients?
Shame on you, Great White, for engaging in something as mindless as setting off fireworks indoors, for doing so without written confirmation from the Derderians as to the club’s fire safety, and for seeking immunity in the evolving grand jury investigation so you cannot be held responsible for your careless actions. Your heavy metal band’s need to add sparks to a concert set off an explosion that can never be squelched, no matter how much is shelled out in damages.
Speaking of money ... beyond the cost of pain and death, this fire will no doubt take a catastrophic bite out of the hides of health insurers, Medicaid programs, hospitals, surviving victims, and the state’s liability insurers. On medical treatment alone, the burn care that’s required is exorbitant. There are approximately 80 patients who will need it, some more extensively than others. Estimates predict the cost for survivor medical care could be a whopping $500,000 each. I cannot even fathom where it could go punitively.
All of this to save a measly $600 by not buying the non-flammable grade of foam.
All of this to make a sale.
All of this to give club-goers a light show they’d remember.
The legal banter now volleying between clients and attorneys, each scrambling for damage control and protection, makes me think of rats scurrying for cover. You can run but you cannot hide from the truth. As a result of your actions, each of you helped sign 98 death certificates and permanently wounded even more lives.
Lastly, I have another blazing concern. It has been reported that fire inspectors who had routinely visited the club — including an inspection a mere two months ago — had not noticed the polyurethane foam insulation around the stage. (Allegedly, the foam was put up in 2000.)
To me, that’s a bit like a gastroenterologist performing a colonoscopy and accidentally overlooking a large malignant polyp peeking back at him. Oops.
While I have the greatest respect for firefighters — selfless professionals who regularly exhibit bravery and quick, capable, lifesaving judgment — I cannot help but feel angry at hearing this three-alarm tidbit. (An investigation into this possible dereliction of duty is currently under way.)
The Technical Committee of the National Fire Protection Association, an international nonprofit organization dedicated to reducing the worldwide burden of fire and other hazards, has been asked by the Rhode Island state fire marshal’s office to assist with the review of this dreadful incident. (The NFPA provides and advocates scientifically based consensus codes and standards, research, training and education.)
Arthur E. Cote, NFPA executive vice president, said in wake of these recent public assembly tragedies — first, a deadly crowd crush in a Chicago club on Feb. 17 which killed 21 patrons; now, Rhode Island — a serious review and scrutiny of the future direction of codes and standards and their enforcement is warranted.
Amen to that. But it’s not going to do diddly for the folks affected by this tremendous breach of responsibility.
It’s all so disgusting. It was all so preventable. And that’s what really burns me up.
Diana Sevanian is a Signal staff writer. Her commentary appears Saturdays and she can be reached by e-mail at [email protected].
