It was a big day not only for the law-and-order crowd but also for voters throughout California, who’ve seen their decisions at the ballot box overturned too many times by the folks in the black robes.
On Tuesday the U.S. Supreme Court, in several separate decisions, upheld the Golden State’s three-strikes law and made it tougher for convicted sex offenders to go unnoticed in their communities.
It was a slim majority, but a majority nonetheless, which sent the message that career felons should expect to do the time if they’re going to do the crime, and that they’ll have to live with the consequences of their actions.
Californians have been frustrated with the state’s criminal justice system ever since the Rose Bird court threw out the state’s 1976 death-penalty statute. The 1980s brought Bird’s removal along with the mantra, “use a gun, go to prison.” But violent offenders continued to slip through the cracks, and when 12-year-old Polly Klaas was brutalized and strangled to death in 1993 by a twice-convicted kidnapper whose criminal record stretched back to 1967, the tune changed to “three strikes and you’re out.”
California Attorney General Bill Lockyer’s deputies convinced the court majority that the intent of the state’s three-strikes law is to look at what one might call the “whole criminal,” and mete out justice accordingly. It isn’t about the theft of some golf clubs or videotapes, but rather the removal of sociopaths from the streets before they have an opportunity to strike again, and even more savagely.
“When the California Legislature enacted the three-strikes law, it made a judgment that protecting the public safety requires incapacitating criminals who have already been convicted of at least one serious or violent crime,” Justice Sandra Day O’Connor wrote in her majority opinion.
Opposing attorneys wrongly sought to make it a case of the punishment fitting the sole and specific “third strike” that earned their clients an extended prison stay.
“If these sentences aren’t cruel and unusual punishment, what would be?” asked Erwin Cemerinsky, the oft-quoted USC law professor whose client, a career burglar, made the conscious decision to break the law again and earned back-to-back 25-year sentences.
Cruel and unusual is what it would be if a violent sex offender lived on your block and you didn’t have any good way to know it.
In cases from Alaska and Connecticut, the justices decided by wide margins that the public’s got a right to keep tabs on ex-cons who might commit more sex crimes.
It was the court’s first review of various Megan’s laws, the sex-offender registry laws that were adopted in one form or another in every state after the 1994 kidnapping, rape and murder of 7-year-old Megan Kanka by a paroled pervert who lived in her New Jersey neighborhood.
In a case that is likely to have a direct impact in Los Angeles County and throughout California, the court said it’s OK for states to post pictures of convicted sex offenders on the Internet.
“Our system does not treat dissemination of truthful information in furtherance of a legitimate governmental objection as punishment,” wrote Justice Anthony Kennedy, addressing arguments that felons who’ve served their time for sex crimes might be humiliated if they’re continually monitored.
Justice David Souter was careful to note that Tuesday’s rulings dealt only with narrow aspects of the new tough-on-crime laws. More constitutional challenges are likely to come.
But for the citizens of California who’ve grown weary from standing up to criminals only to have their legal legs pulled out from under them, Tuesday was a good day.
