“Dad, should we be going to war?”
The question stopped me in my tracks, a frozen waffle in one hand and a child-proof plastic bottle of dinosaur vitamins in the other.
I was in the middle of my usual morning breakfast prep, part of the routine in which I get the kids ready, then take my 7-year-old son to school and my 20-month-old daughter to day care before going off to work.
My wife, who had also fielded some war inquiries the previous night while driving Luc home from basketball practice, was already off to work; she has the early work schedule, so I get weekday morning breakfast duty.
And on this particular morning, Tough Question Duty.
It was just a few hours before Friday’s so-called “shock and awe” campaign began, the fiery bombing of Baghdad that has given us, if nothing else, the catch phrase that will inevitably find its way into the American vernacular and be part of our conversations for years to come. “Shock and Awe” will become, if you will, the Mother of All Catch Phrases.
We’d been at war for a couple of days already, and the casualties had been minimal — but our troops on the ground hadn’t yet reached the uncertainty of greater Baghdad. Catch-phrase amusement and gee-whiz bombing footage aside, it’s a fair question to ask:
Are we doing the right thing?
I’d been pondering the question myself for the past few weeks. I like to consider myself capable of drawing my own conclusions on difficult issues, but I’d been having a tough time with this one because I really could see compelling arguments on both sides.
Anti-war: Saddam wasn’t directly involved in 9/11. We haven’t been attacked by Saddam. This is a pre-emptive strike, and I’ve always held on to the romantic notion that we only shoot in anger when provoked, or when our allies are attacked. Yes, we were attacked on Sept. 11, but last time anyone checked, Osama isn’t in Iraq.
Pro-war: Saddam is damn dangerous and, unlike North Korea, he can in all likelihood be defeated with relatively few American casualties. He has ties to terrorists, he hates America and, given the time and opportunity, he most certainly would continue developing “weapons of mass destruction” and share them with people who would use them against us. If war with Iraq has a chance of preventing a repeat of 9/11, then war it shall be.
I have cursed myself for being wishy washy on it. I’d much rather stake out a well-chosen position and defend it, for better or for worse. Like I said, I’d been turning the whole thing over in my head, sincerely wanting a good, firm, ambivalence-killing conclusion.
I’d failed to come to one.
Now, my second-grader was forcing the issue.
They say the worst time to have a son is 20 years before a war. Lucky enough for my folks, I was born in 1966, a pretty good year to have a son because the mid-’80s were relatively uneventful in terms of our nation’s involvement in armed conflict. I hope like hell 1995 proves to be a good year, too, and don’t think for a second that such things haven’t been crossing my mind lately. My heart goes out to all the moms and dads of the troops who’ve gone off to war. If my son has a healthy distaste for the concept of war, I selfishly will not object.
I told Luc I hate the idea of war, that I think it should be a last resort, and it makes me very sad to think of soldiers and innocent people who might be killed — emphasizing to him, of course, that this is all happening way on the other side of the world and that here, at home, he and I are not in any immediate danger.
Kids worry about such things.
I told him a lot of people think we should have been able to resolve our differences with Saddam Hussein without bombs and guns, but that others believe Saddam understands no other method of persuasion, that he supports other “bad guys” and has oppressed his people for many years.
I basically gave him both sides of the story, and I reminded him that, no matter what we think about the things that led us to war, it’s important for us to be supportive to the people who are risking their lives on our behalf.
After stammering my lengthy non-answer and spewing some $50 words I learned in college political science class — stuff that I thought would cruise right over my boy’s head like an outbound Tomahawk — I turned the question back around on him.
“So, Luc, what do you think? Should we be going to war?”
He thought about it. He agreed with me on the subtexts, saying he hated the idea of war, and that he never wanted to know anyone who’s killed in a war.
Then the rapidly aging 7-year-old did what his old man hasn’t been able to do: He drew a conclusion.
“If it will make the future safer, we should.”
Well, there we go.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
