History is an artform best written with a pencil. That way you can correct it.
As the lower case historian for this august valley, I’ve been teaching a 10-week course through Golden Oak Adult School for many years now. (The Spring semester starts Tuesday. Best you climb out of your crumb-encrusted sofa and call 253-0583 to register.) I always reserve about an hour to talk about the St. Francis Dam Disaster.
I remember getting the call, right after Jerry Reynolds died. That beloved rascal had taught the class before me. I was doing my Time Ranger history columns and someone over at Golden Oak mistook that for being scholarly. They asked if I could take over for Jerry and lecture at 10 — count them, 10 — three hour classes, three semesters a year.
While I had a few hundred anecdotes, I possessed nothing close to a curriculum and spent the first semester exactly one bend ahead of the posse, or, in this case, that first class.
So, the first few semesters, I confidently shared the when the old St. Francis burst its banks in 1928, it let loose a wall of water nearly 200 feet high down San Francisquito Canyon, taking the lives of around 500 poor-swimming souls.
As it had been passed down to me, the SFDD was “…the second worse man-made disaster in American history.” That’d be right after the San Francisco Fire in the early 20th century.
Then, I’m watching TV one night way back when and there is a documentary on the Johnstown Flood of 1889. After a dam failed about this Pennsylvania industrial town, a wall of water 35 feet high rolled down, killing over 2,000 folks.
So. I had to get out the pencil and revise my notes. This now pushed The St. Francis Dam Disaster to the bronze medal position of The Third Worst Man-Made Disaster in American history.
Wouldn’t you know it, I was perusing some news sites the other day and you guessed it. I found another MMD that topped in severity our ever-shrinking St. Francis leakage.
On April 16, 1947, an errant cigarette tossed on a ship loaded with ammonium nitrate killed around 800 and injured 5,000. Ammonium nitrate was the chemical that scurvy psycho Timothy McVeigh used a few years back to blow up the federal building in Oklahoma City.
For those who have the unpleasant duty of categorizing and ranking such things, this factory explosion is ranked as the worst industrial disaster in American history. Be it dam or factory, I believe that constitutes a man-made disaster, which now pushes our St. Francis tragedy of 75 years ago out of the medal category into fourth spot.
Interestingly, while ammonium nitrate took the lives of so many in Oklahoma City, the episode in the Lone Star state 56 years back occurred in a town called Texas City. It nearly wiped the place off the map.
Texas City used to be in Galveston Bay, about 40 miles south of Houston.
Grandcamp, the ship carrying the deadly cargo, was French, by the way. It was being loaded with 2,300 tons of the stuff from the nearby Texas chemical factory.
Ammonium nitrate was used during World War II. It made a powerful explosive and a very strong fertilizer. When the cargo ship blew, it knocked airplanes out of the sky miles away. The explosion shook buildings hundreds of miles away.
I remember reading about this tragedy and odd mind that I have, I wanted to know just how in the heck they knew the blast was started by someone flinging a spent cigarette. I’m guessing there wasn’t even vapor left of the guy flicking the lit butt, let alone the eye witness standing next to him who spotted the worst case scenario of littering.
According to Bill Minutaglio, author of “City on Fire,” the chronicle of this Texas disaster, the blast was 300 times more powerful than the Oklahoma City bombing of 1995, which killed 168 people. Worse, occurring in a heavy industrialized area of chemical plants and oil refineries, it kicked off a series of other explosions and fires and ended up destroying — literally — thousands of buildings. The dead were found floating in Galveston Bay. The anchor to the French cargo ship — which weighed 3,000 pounds — went airborne and was found two miles away. It still sits as a monument to that horrendous morning.
Survivors of the victims and those injured each received $12,000 from the federal government. Curiously, while the Texas City explosion was the worst industrial accident in American history, it is also the forgotten disaster.
Years later, I now know that a small detail had been erroneously passed along: the St. Francis Dam wasn’t the second worst man-made disaster in American history. It was the second-worst man-made disaster in California history. And certainly, it was the worst darn thing that ever happened in Saugus.
John Boston’s Mr. Santa Clarita Valley column appears Wednesday through Saturday. To reach Boston, dial 259-1234, ext. 242.
