California ranks close to the bottom in terms of a fair liability law system, according to a recent nationwide survey of corporate attorneys.
The United States Chamber of Commerce survey gave the state an overall ranking of 44th among the 50 states.
In-house general counselors and senior litigators in corporate America classified the state as one of the five worst in jury predictability and treatment of punitive damages and class action lawsuits.
The state was ranked 48th in jury predictability; ranked 45th in the timelines of summary judgment or dismissal; 44th in the treatment of class action suits; 44th in jury fairness; 44th in discovery; 41th in punitive damages; 37th in judges’ impartiality; 32nd in judges’ competence; and 30th in scientific and technical evidence.
Of the corporate attorneys surveyed by the U.S. Chamber’s Institute of Legal Reform, 82 percent said the impact of a states litigation environment is an important factor when deciding where to do business or locate a new facility. Sixteen percent said a states litigation environment does not affect important business decisions.
John Sullivan, president of the Civil Justice Association of California, said in a statement the other bad news in California is the state is also getting worse in terms of a fair liability law system.
“While some of the bottom rung states are on an improvement track, California is heading in the opposite direction on a road to perdition,” Sullivan said. The explosion of private lawyer shakedown lawsuits under California business practice law is bound to lower our already dismal ranking in the class action lawsuit category.”
Sullivan said while Mississippi, which ranked 50th, recently enacted tort reform, California was continuing to erode its law.
He said personal injury lawyers in the state over are lobbying to change the states law that permits early dismissal of frivolous lawsuits, and that a change would certainly drop the states ranking even lower.
“The Legal Institute survey is a guide book on where not to go if you want to keep your company from bleeding away jobs and income in excessive litigation,” he said. “Add this to all the tax, fee and other cost problems facing firms of all size in California and you come up with recipe for economic declines.”
