Opponents of a Senate bill that would add a tax to diapers have put the city of Santa Clarita’s experimental diaper recycling program directly in their sights.
Leading the charge is the California Manufacturers and Technology Association, an industry group whose membership roster includes Procter & Gamble, the maker of Pampers and Luvs-brand diapers.
Alleging that the city’s program hasn’t achieved its goals, CMTA and others are seeking defeat for SB 204 by Sen. Don Perata, D-Oakland. The bill would levy a quarter-cent tax on personal care products — defined as “a disposable product composed of plastic and paper materials that is worn by a person of any age for the purpose of capturing human waste” — to fund municipal programs that would divert the products from California landfills.
“A state-subsidized pilot project began last year in (Santa Clarita). Early reports affirm the value of using curbside diaper recycling,” Perata said in a Feb. 14 statement when he introduced the bill.
But CMTA representative Mitch Gorsen said the group objects to a law that would tax one disposable product over another.
“(CMTA’s) position on this is that if you’re going to put a tax on one product that goes into a landfill, then you can tax other products that go into a landfill,” he said. “It’s a bad precedent to single out one product.”
Gorsen said the city of Santa Clarita saved, at most, $18.15 — eighteen dollars — in dumping fees from November 2002 to March 2003, while diverting less than 2 percent of the weight of the diapers from landfills.
He pointed to a Feb. 19 interoffice memo from City Manager Ken Pulskamp to the City Council in which Pulskamp reported, “To staff’s knowledge, nothing has been diverted from landfilling during this pilot program except for that which has been sewered (human waste), and the plastic residuals that have remained on-site (at the recycling facility) in Sun Valley.”
However, city officials said Thursday that the diversion numbers have changed since the February memo.
Several technical problems with the processing machine during a four-month period caused there to be too few diapers recycled to produce any data, said Jason Smisko, the city’s interim environmental services manager. And Assistant City Manager Jill Fosselman said the machine began recycling enough of the diapers only in the last five to six weeks.
The city launched the pilot six-month program last November with Knowaste LLC, which is the sole maker of diaper-recycling machinery. The city purchased the diaper recycling processor from Knowaste with $250,000 in city funds and $250,000 in state funds.
The diapers are being collected from about 230 participating homes from four different neighborhoods in Santa Clarita. Hauler Blue Barrel Disposal transports the diapers down to the processor, which is housed at rival hauler Browning Ferris Industries’ facility in Sun Valley.
The recycled fiber pulp from the diapers is then brought back up to Quality Paper, the Santa Clarita-based recycling firm, where it is then sold and carted to a company in Pomona.
Smisko said nearly 24 tons of diapers have been collected through the program to date, and Chris Fall, district sales manager for Blue Barrel, said about a ton of pulp fiber has been recovered.
BFI has not been charging the $28-per-ton dumping fee — nor any water or sewer fees — as outlined in the pilot program contract between the city and Knowaste, Fosselman said.
“It’s not a cost issue,” Knowaste attorney Hunt Braly said. “It’s a public policy issue: Should human waste be sent to a landfill?”
“The technology exists to reuse virtually the entire diaper, while safely disposing of the human waste. We can make a wide variety of products from the plastic and guarantee that no toxins seep into the soil or aquifers, long a concern of public health officials,” said Perata, whose senate campaign committee received a $2,500 contribution from Knowaste on Oct. 29.
City Council members will be asked next month to decide whether to renew and possibly expand the program.
Braly said another six-month run of the pilot program would not cost the city any more money, and would provide more information on how successful the program could be.
The City Council approved the diaper recycling program by a 4-1 vote in 2001, despite a negative report from hired engineering consultants and a staff recommendation that the program would be too expensive.
Councilman Bob Kellar, the lone dissenter, said he believed a larger city would be better suited for a pilot program of this magnitude because it could better absorb the cost.
“It was disconcerting to me because the staff recommended against it,” Kellar said Thursday.
He said he is waiting to receive a staff report on the program before he decides whether to support it the second time around.
Listed opponents of SB 204 are the CMTA; the California Chamber of Commerce; the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association; diaper manufacturer Kimberly-Clark Corp.; Cal-Tax; the California Association of Health Facilities; and Californians Allied Against Regressive Taxation.
Official supporters include the California League of Conservation Voters; Californians Against Waste; Clean Water Action; the Planning and Conservation League; Environment California; the city of Richmond; Calleguas Municipal Water District; Inland Empire Utilities Agency; Bolsa Chica Land Trust; and Ocean Outfall Group.
