ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Are you sure you’re shopping locally?

“Shop Local.” The bad grammar isn’t the most confusing part of that little two-word slogan. It means different things to different people.

And now come the leaders of the Stevenson Ranch Town Council — sorry, West Ranch, whatever — with a new and even more confounding “Don’t Shop Local” campaign.

If nothing else, their effort provokes a definition of just what it means to “shop local,” and a discussion of who wants you to shop where and why. So let’s shop around for an answer.

Let’s start at Santa Clarita City Hall, and specifically on the third floor of the City Hall building where most of the city government bureaucrats hang out. You’ll learn why we’re starting on the third floor in a moment.

To a city official, “Shop Local” means you should patronize businesses within the city’s geographical boundaries. Why? Because every time you plop down one of your hard-earned dollars on a durable good or a processed food item inside city limits, a penny goes into the city’s general fund.

Every year, that adds up to millions upon millions of pennies, which the city throws back at its citizens in the form of services — police, fire, roads, parks and so forth. More pennies, more services.

The city really loves it when “outsiders” patronize businesses with a Santa Clarita address. Why? Because these people come in, spend their money and leave. In the process, they feed a penny on the dollar to the city’s kitty without getting much of anything from the city in return, and without costing the city too much (except wear and tear of roads, and if they’re troublemakers, maybe police services.)

This is why the city spends some of your tax money to hype big-ticket events like the SBC Classic and the Cowboy Poetry Festival. The return — dollars spent by tourists at restaurants and hotels in the city — far outweighs the cost.

Got it? Good. Now let’s ride the elevator down to the first floor at City Hall. This is where the Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce leases office space.

Ask a chamber official, and she’ll have a different answer about the meaning of “Shop Local.” To a chamber executive, “Shop Local” means you should patronize any business that belongs to the chamber, regardless of whether it’s located inside the city of Santa Clarita’s jurisdictional boundaries. And by extension, it means you should patronize any business in the Santa Clarita Valley.

Why? Because it helps the entire local economy when you spend your money in our valley.

Let’s say you live here and work in downtown Los Angeles, and let’s say you decide to buy, oh — a refrigerator on your lunch hour. (Let’s say you drive a big truck to haul it in.) What have you done? You’ve spent money that you’ve earned in Los Angeles, in Los Angeles. Not only have you given a penny on the dollar to the Los Angeles city government, but you’ve also helped a Los Angeles business owner make ends meet, and you’ve helped him make payroll.

Now let’s say you delay your refrigerator purchase until the weekend and you decide to buy one from — oh, let’s say Caston’s TV & Appliance in Newhall. Now what have you done? Not only have you given a penny on the dollar to the government that will turn around and spend it on you (if you live inside the city of Santa Clarita), but you’ve helped Jerry clear out some of his inventory and you’ve helped him put food on his employees’ tables.

Just think what would happen if all of your friends and neighbors delayed their shopping experience until they were back home in the Santa Clarita Valley. The Jerry Castons out there would have to hire more employees — maybe even your own kids.

The crazy city boundaries that were drawn 15 years ago on a Santa Clarita Valley map don’t mean much when you’re a chamber official whose responsibility it is to help chamber members in particular, regardless of which side of the line they’re on, and bolster the local economy in general. Businesses just outside city limits — for instance, at the Valencia Marketplace — don’t check for Santa Clarita green cards. They’re likely to employ any number of people who live inside city limits, and who will, in turn, spend some of their earnings at a burger joint on the city’s side of the fence.

Confused? What has me really confused is this “Don’t Shop Local” campaign, proffered by members of the Stevenson Ranch Town Council (sorry, did it again) who are upset that the city of Santa Clarita might give city residents first chance at signing up for city parks and recreation programs.

I won’t delve into the rationale for this “boycott” here. Rather, let’s figure out what it is that these folks want you to do.

Knowing the Santa Clarita Auto Mall is the single biggest source of sales tax revenue for the city — the city gets lots of pennies when you buy a car — they’re asking their Stevenson Ranch neighbors to kindly avoid Creekside Road and instead do their car shopping in the San Fernando Valley.

Now, let’s ponder this. The Town Council members rightly note that the County of Los Angeles is responsible for providing services to Stevenson Ranch — the police, fire protection and so forth that I mentioned earlier.

And, Stevenson Ranch is located in unincorporated county territory, so every time a shopper — whether a city resident, a non-city resident or a French expatriate — spends a dollar at a restaurant or business in Stevenson Ranch, a portion goes to the County of Los Angeles in the form of sales tax, which the county theoretically uses to provide services to Stevenson Ranch.

(Never mind, for today, that the Valencia Marketplace, which is outside city limits, is one of the largest retail centers in Los Angeles County and generates more sales-tax revenue for the county than it costs to provide services to Stevenson Ranch.)

The confusing part is this notion of buying a car in the San Fernando Valley.

What’s the closest, biggest, most prominent, best known auto dealership in the San Fernando Valley? Galpin Ford. And where’s Galpin Ford? It’s in North Hills, which is part of the city of Los Angeles. So what happens when you buy a car from Galpin Ford instead of from Power Ford in Valencia, or even from Galpin’s sister dealership here, Saturn of Santa Clarita?

What happens is that a penny of every dollar you spend goes to the city government — the government of the city of Los Angeles, which pumps it back into services for whom? For residents of the city of Los Angeles.

OK, so you skip Galpin and shop at some other Southland auto mall. Still you’re handing over your sales-tax pennies to some other city, which is spending your money not on you, but on its own residents. Not to mention that you’re putting food on the table of some Southland business owner who’s likely to employ few, if any, Santa Clarita Valley residents.

You’re not helping Stevenson Ranch, or anyone else in the Santa Clarita Valley.

Talk about cutting off your nose to spite your face.

You want to help Santa Clarita? You want to help Stevenson Ranch? Shop locally — and Shop Local.

Leon Worden is The Signal’s city editor. His commentary appears Wednesdays.

← Back to 2003

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-vs:2250.
System
ViewStory pages (/News/ViewStory.asp)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,245 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
viewstory:font_body
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [city editor]
  • text:valley_names [6 distinct/31 mentions: Santa Clarita, Valencia, Newhall, Stevenson Ranch, West Ranch, Chamber of Commerce]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 6, national 0