The phrase “sour grapes” inevitably comes to mind. It’s the obvious pun that’s conjured when one hears of the Agua Dulce winery’s dispute with some apparently cranky neighbors who sound as if they should have a nice glass of merlot and relax a little.
Yes, perhaps we’re getting ahead of ourselves. Perhaps the complaining neighbors are not simply a bunch of NIMBYs who don’t like having anything in their back yard that makes their area a popular place for outsiders to visit.
We must allow for the possibility that there are some real, legitimate issues that need to be addressed if Agua Dulce Vineyards is to continue doing business along that rural stretch of Sierra Highway between Saugus and Acton.
The devil is often in the details, and we expect over the next few months to see exactly how the details unfold.
For now, though, Agua Dulce Vineyards has been ordered to shut down while Los Angeles County processes its application for a conditional use permit, the land use entitlement that’s needed for the winery to continue on an ongoing basis.
The winery had been operating under a special “clean hands waiver” that allowed it to open in October 2001 without the permit. That permission was revoked April 8 by James Hartl, Los Angeles County’s planning director, who told the winery to put a cork in it after 30 residents sent a petition to the county complaining about the winery.
The critics’ grape gripes include noise pollution, traffic congestion and water issues.
Again, perhaps some of those concerns are legitimate — and maybe there’s more to the situation than meets the eye. But there’s no mistaking the fact that it would be a crying shame if relatively few residents are able to permanently shut down a very successful start-up that has brought a welcome new flavor — literally and figuratively — not just to the fringes of the Santa Clarita Valley but also to northern Los Angeles County in general.
The winery at times the past year and a half has been the talk of the town. Many Santa Claritans have visited to taste and purchase locally produced wines, and perhaps enjoy a picnic on the vineyard grounds. It’s difficult to imagine anyone viewing the winery as an unwelcome addition to the community. It draws an upscale clientele and what appears to be a modest amount of traffic, and the vineyards are certainly more pleasing to the eye than row upon row of identical tract houses would be.
If you take a leisurely Sunday drive up Sierra Highway — which, after all, is a public road — you’ll find that the rows of vines have made a rather pleasing addition to the rural landscape, reminiscent of the “wine country” in other parts of California.
And you’ll likely find that, while the winery has resulted in an increased number of vehicle trips on a sunny weekend, it hasn’t exactly turned Sierra Highway into a gridlocked city street, either.
Truly, there are worse things that could be added to a neighborhood.
Obviously, Agua Dulce Vineyards must do whatever is reasonably necessary to get its permit squared away, and that includes taking steps to address any legitimate concerns that have been raised by opponents. And if it has made any missteps along the way, it is incumbent upon the winery to rectify them.
However, we would also expect that the county would do whatever it can, within reason, to allow such a popular and generally harmless business to continue operating. If the winery were put out of business simply because a few dozen people don’t want it there, that doesn’t seem to be sufficient reason.
We suppose the responsible thing to do is to reserve judgment and see how the permit process plays out — so we will — but our first sniff of this particular glass of community opposition smells like something that spent too many years in the bottle.
