Well, this just hasn’t penciled out so far.
I like the high-minded purpose of recycling dirty diapers. Truly, I do. An estimated 18 billion disposable diapers are dumped in landfills every year, and that’s a shame.
There are, of course, obvious debates about disposable vs. cloth diapers. Cloth is widely viewed as the more environmentally friendly alternative, while some studies still contend that cloth diapers consume more energy and water while creating more air pollution than their manufactured counterpart.
Whatever. The fact of the matter is, people are going to use disposable diapers. I don’t see that freight train stopping any time soon.
This, of course, prompts those of us who wish to do right by our planet to wonder: Can those things be recycled?
It depends.
The city of Santa Clarita is the first municipality in California to embark on a pilot program to recycle junior’s dirty didies, in a partnership with a company called Knowaste that is the only company that has developed a machine for this purpose.
The machine is designed to remove the — ahem — human waste from diapers, then break the actual diapers down into reusable materials.
Santa Clarita’s program is now under a statewide microscope, because of a political debate brewing in Sacramento over a piece of legislation that would tax diapers in order to provide grants to cities for diaper recycling. Of course, no one stands to gain more from that than Knowaste. After all, if cities want to score points with environmentalists by recycling diapers, who else could they hire?
The diaper manufacturers, obviously, oppose the legislation. They correctly point out that it’s a bit onerous to tax one disposable product when no other disposable product faces such a tax, but make no mistake: The opposition will be guided by business principles, not environmental ones.
All of these vested interests are typical of many political battles these days, and I view both sides with a healthy dose of cynicism. I’m sure there will be much arm-twisting and campaign fund-raising associated with the resolution of the diaper issue, and that will surprise no one in Sacramento.
The real question we should all be asking, though, is, “Will it work?”
That is, can we recycle diapers in a way that is both environmentally friendly and cost-effective?
The Santa Clarita pilot program has only been rolling for a bit under six months, but the answer at this stage of the game is, no.
I have never weighed a soiled diaper.
However, I checked on the Internet and found a scale that is designed for just such a purpose. (No, really.) The capacity of the scale was 600 grams, which is equivalent to 21 ounces. If you figure 21 ounces is a “heavy” diaper, it’s a pretty safe argument that an “average” diaper — from a baby, anyway — weighs about a pound.
For the sake of argument, let’s go with a half-pound per diaper, which will make this calculation more conservative, thus tilting the scales, if you will, toward recycling.
So. Figure we’ve recycled 80,000 diapers in six months. That means, so far, we’ve spent $6.25 for each diaper recycled.
And, even if we were to assume that the program were to continue for another six months at no more cost, if the results were similar we’d still be spending $3.17 per diaper.
It costs about $28 to dump a TON of trash at a landfill. So, for the same amount it would cost to recycle, say, nine diapers, you can dump 8,000 of them.
Call it fuzzy math if you want. Call it poopy math. But I’m betting I can’t be too far off, and in fact the dollars-for-diapers picture may be even more grim than I’m portraying it to be. This is expensive, and as other observers have pointed out, diaper recycling will not happen, at this stage of the game, without heavy government subsidies.
I applaud those who want to do the right thing. But there also must come a point at which we balance doing the right thing with what’s practical. Spending $6 — or even $3 — to recycle a single diaper just is not practical, especially when you take into account the fact, as reported by city staff, that diapers only account for 1.4 percent of the waste stream. They figure, if the diaper recycling program is successful, we might divert a half of a percent from our local waste stream.
Finally: The city staff estimates that the cost of landfilling the 40,000 pounds of diapers would have been $700, versus the half-million dollars in state and city funds that have been spent on the pilot program.
Not exactly stunning results.
The city of Santa Clarita is to be commended for trying to be on the leading edge of something like this. Without innovation, we don’t progress. But Councilman Bob Kellar was right last year when he cast the council’s lone dissenting vote on the issue, saying it would be too expensive and such a program might be better suited to a larger city that could better “absorb” the cost. (Don’t think the verb choice got past us, Bob...)
Perhaps the time will come for widespread diaper recycling. But if the minimal results from the city’s pilot program are any indication, it will not arrive any time soon.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays, and he can be reached by calling 259-1234, ext. 234.
