A Superior Court judge announced Monday that she has ruled in favor of the city of Santa Clarita and The Newhall Land and Farming Co. in a lawsuit challenging the expansion of the Valencia auto mall.
The lawsuit, filed last year by the Center for Biological Diversity and Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment, alleged the city did not follow the state-mandated environmental process in approving the four new car dealerships adjacent to the Santa Clara River.
“We’re very pleased the judge recognized that the environmental documents were done appropriately,” said Newhall Land spokeswoman Marlee Lauffer.
The company does not yet have a timeline for when construction on the auto dealerships will begin, she said.
Judge Dzintra Janavs announced the decision in an informal ruling, Lauffer said.
Peter Galvin, California and Pacific director of CBD, said he was extremely disappointed with the ruling.
“We felt strongly that we had a good case,” Galvin said. “We feel strongly that we were wronged by the court. There were large errors in the way (Janavs) came to her decision.”
The city last week submitted to the court a correction to its environmental review regarding construction air emissions.
Responding to allegations that the ruling was unfair because it did not allow for members of the public to comment on the submitted correction, City Attorney Carl Newton said corrections do not require public hearings.
“The corrections really were a clarification of records that were before the (Santa Clarita City Council),” Newton said.
He said the correction was not part of the official record, and needed to be submitted to become official. The judge’s decision needed to be based on official records, he said.
SCOPE President Lynne Plambeck called the decision “not unexpected.”
“The judge allowed them to put in the information on Wednesday, and then decided today,” she said. “This is the most incredible thing. I’ve never seen anything like this.
“I’m frustrated. Not only can we expect unfair hearings from the city, but now from the court system, too,” Plambeck said.
The City Council voted to approve the auto dealership expansion off of Valencia Boulevard in July, despite protests from environmental activists.
As part of the auto mall expansion, Newhall Land has agreed to $100,000 in improvements to the neighboring William S. Hart PONY and softball fields, including river bank stabilization, floodway protection, construction of a bike and pedestrian trail into the facility, and installation of a traffic signal at its entrance.
“We’re very focused on bringing the improvements to the Hart PONY fields to fruition,” Lauffer said.
Plambeck said Newhall Land has focused primarily on the softball fields — rather than the auto mall expansion — in the lawsuit and in public comment to make the organizations opposing the project look bad.
“This is an auto mall project. The PONY leagues were already there,” Plambeck said. “They’re trying to control public opinion by how they refer to (the project).”
On Jan. 31, Newhall Land posted a sign in front of the softball fields’ entrance that stated improvements in the facility were being delayed by CBD and SCOPE.
“They can make the improvements any time they wanted,” Plambeck said. “People can get to the fields the same way the have for 20 years.”
Newton said Janavs’ decision will be formalized in a judgment later this month.
