Say good-bye to your $22.13 monthly trash bill.
Six trash haulers submitted bids this week for the city of Santa Clarita’s residential and commercial solid waste contracts, with proposed monthly rates ranging from $14.75 to more than $25.
Blue Barrel Disposal entered the lowest bid, which would drop the current monthly rate by more than $7, despite the company’s previous claims that it could not offer a lower rate to residents.
Blue Barrel currently shares the city’s trash hauling services with Consolidated Disposal Service, which also filed a bid for the city’s exclusive contracts.
Consolidated, a subsidiary of Republic Services Inc., offered an $18.29-per-month rate.
The remaining proposals came from Burrtec Waste Industries, at $16.46; Browning Ferris Industries, at $17.80; Crown Disposal Co., at $18.76; and E.J. Harrison & Sons, at $25.25 per month.
Browning Ferris Industries
The nation’s second-largest solid waste management company raised the stakes earlier this week when it revealed it would offer the city 400 acres of coveted land in Elsmere Canyon if it is awarded both the city’s residential and commercial trash contracts.
BFI’s proposal states that if the land is rejected, it will instead discount residents $1 per home, per month.
Also included in the company’s proposal are unlimited residential and commercial recycling; guaranteed disposal capacity for the city at its Sunshine Canyon Landfill; and a $50,000-per-year donation for the city to use to support charitable and community events. If awarded both contracts, BFI will double the amount to $100,000.
Further, if the city awards both residential and commercial contracts to the company, BFI has offered a 3-percent discount off its $17.80-per-month bid.
Burrtec Waste Industries, Inc.
Burrtec’s proposal includes a plan to develop a material recovery facility (MRF) within the city of Santa Clarita.
“Burrtec believes this to be the only feasible approach to accomplishing the diversion and solving long-term solid waste handling needs in the city,” the company’s proposal states.
The largest privately held solid waste organization in California, Burrtec said it has been working with a local developer and has identified three potential sites; however, the company states in its offer that it will not discuss the sites until the selection process progresses further.
Burrtec’s proposal includes a “Santa Clarita Beautification Grant Program,” in which the company will contribute an additional $3 each quarter for each ton of residential recyclables recovered at its future MRF.
“This program will make funds available via grants for activities that beautify areas visible from public rights-of-way. Groups eligible for these grants will include homeowner associations, neighborhood organizations, apartment complexes, schools and libraries,” the proposal states.
Consolidated Disposal Service
One of the city’s incumbent haulers, Consolidated is offering to cut Santa Clarita residents’ monthly rate by nearly $3, and proposes a 1.25-percent discount if it is awarded both residential and commercial contracts.
Consolidated included in its proposal an incentive program for residents to help reach the city’s specific recycling goals.
The city is requiring any hauler to meet a state-mandated diversion goal of 50 percent by the second calendar quarter of service. The city’s ultimate goal is to reach a 75-percent diversion rate.
Consolidated’s “Neighborhood Grant” program would offer $500 to neighborhoods that reach recycling goals — such as percentage increase in diversion rates, or the highest diversion rate over time. The grant would be issued to a charitable organization selected by the neighborhood.
The proposal offers another approach to the program, where Santa Clarita elementary schools would win cash awards based on diversion rates from competing neighborhoods, defined by school district boundaries.
Crown Disposal Co. Inc.
Crown’s claims it will exceed the city’s minimum diversion requirements in the first year of operation. The hauler took over the city of San Fernando’s residential trash franchise in 2002 and increased diversion from 24 percent to 56 percent within six months, Crown’s proposal states.
“A key Crown Disposal goal is to ensure that the city of Santa Clarita is recognized as a premier recycling city, with diversion rates among the highest in California,” it states.
If the city awards both residential and commercial contracts to the company, Crown will offer a 2-percent discount off its proposed $18.76 monthly rate.
In its proposal, Crown taxes exception to the city’s request to share revenues from the sale of recyclables. The city would collect $2.50 for each ton diverted from the waste stream.
“Imposing a fee on recyclables recovered through a waste sorting system, recyclables that otherwise would have gone to a landfill would certainly be a financial disincentive to increased diversion efforts,” Crown’s proposal states. “This fee increases processing costs, and discourages MRF activities that ‘push the envelope’ on diversion rates and material sorting strategies.”
E.J. Harrison & Sons
Ventura County-based E.J. Harrison & Sons is at the high end of city’s bidders, weighing in at $25.25 per month for hauling services.
“We are not likely to be the cheapest of the bidders,” the company’s proposal states. “The diversion, clean air and service mandates of the proposed contracts are very stringent. There is no way to meet these goals — our pricing reflects a good faith effort to do so.”
E.J. Harrison serves the cities of Camarillo, Carpinteria, Thousand Oaks and Ventura. The company’s proposal states that its diversion programs are “second to none,” and lists diversion rates for the four contracted cities at 55 percent, 58 percent, 66 percent and 65 percent respectively.
Blue Barrel Disposal
Waste Management Inc. subsidiaries Blue Barrel Disposal and Santa Clarita Disposal are currently responsible for hauling 85 percent of the city’s trash.
In February 2001, Blue Barrel General Manager Karl McCarthy told the Santa Clarita City Council it would be economically unfeasible for Waste Management to reduce its current $22.13 rate. The council, at the time, was considering a renewal of Waste Management’s and Consolidated’s contracts — until BFI preempted the deal by suggesting it would offer Elsmere Canyon in exchange for Santa Clarita’s trash franchise.
The council delayed its decision for a month, voting 4-1 in March 2001 to extend Waste Management’s and Consolidated’s contracts at the current hauling rates.
Two months later, that deal was put on hold when The Signal reported that the city had failed to meet its state-mandated 50-percent recycling requirement. At the same time, it also surfaced that Waste Management was paying $11 a ton to dump its trash at Chiquita Canyon Landfill, while the city had calculated its residential trash rates on the basis of a $34-per-ton dumping fee. Waste Management contested The Signal’s reports of the $11 price until an unrelated lawsuit proved it true.
“That was a different time and a different proposal,” said Chris Fall, Blue Barrel’s local sales manager. “This is the first time we can put our best foot forward by ourselves.”
This time around, Blue Barrel is proposing the lowest rate and has thrown in a special offer.
In addition to responding to the city’s requests, Blue Barrel submitted an alternate proposal, slated “We Can Do It Now.”
If Blue Barrel is selected, it would implement the proposed lower residential rates on Jan. 1, 2004 — rather than waiting until the new residential contract takes effect in April 2006.
The proposal would reduce trash rates 21 percent, saving residents more than $4 million over time.
As second part of its “Do It Now” proposal, Blue Barrel would cut trash collection and recycling costs to area school districts. Schools would be charged only the cost of disposal (tipping fees), with refuse bins provided free of charge.
The offer is good if Santa Clarita gives Blue Barrel a 10-year exclusive contract through 2016.
“We have a lot of history in this town,” Fall said. “We don’t want history to change.”
But the hauler said the city’s requirement for 50-percent waste reduction by the second calendar quarter was unrealistic.
“The proposed requirements are unworkable and may even be impossible to meet,” Blue Barrel’s proposal states. “Based on experience in other jurisdictions, it is highly doubtful that one contractor collecting only a part of the waste stream can meet these very aggressive requirements. In fact, depending upon the waste stream, that level of recyclable commodities may not even exist.”
Fall said the company’s issue is not with meeting the 50-percent or even the 75-percent diversion rate goals. Rather, he said the company would not be handling all of the city’s waste, and does not want the numbers to reflect waste it does not directly manage.
But Blue Barrel said its plan to develop a MRF in Santa Clarita will help the company reach the mandated diversion rates.
“The council made it clear: the best service at the best rate. That’s what they’re looking for,” Fall said.
