The frustration shown by some part-time teachers at College of the Canyons is evident in their elevated voices, accusations that are daggered at the school’s administration, and long-winded descriptions of a lengthy conflict.
This frustration comes from the adjunct faculty saying COC and the full-time teachers’ union are standing in their path to organize a union.
Sixty percent of part-timers at COC have signed authorization cards stating they want the American Federation of Teachers on a union ballot. They are currently without union representation.
The full-timers at the college are represented by the COC Faculty Association affiliated with the California Teachers Association, and have attempted to bring the part-timers into the union after AFT’s initial interest in representing them.
The college would rather deal with one union at the negotiating table.
At a COC board meeting on May 14, many part-timers were still frustrated their message wasn’t sent to the school’s board of trustees. Part-time representatives individually raised their voices to the board, urging them to drop an appeal made to the school regarding a ruling by the Public Employment Relations Board.
The appeal was filed by the school after Los Angeles Superior Court Judge David Yaffe issued an injunction in March 2002, which ordered COC to cease and desist from recognizing COCFA/CTA as the part-timers’ union representative.
Yaffe also ordered the school to cease and desist from encouraging part-time faculty to support one union over another.
The part-timers’ representatives were all in agreement the school was making an error in prolonging the battle over union representation for them, which has lasted since September 2001. The part-timers’ goal at the meeting was to have the board drop the appeal. That didn’t happen.
Some part-timers say the college is not remaining neutral in allowing them to seek representation from AFT, and believe the COCFA/CTA will not fight as fervently for their rights. Additionally, they have made accusations that COCFA/CTA is in the college’s “back pocket” and wants to limit concessions to the part-timers.
The union and school deny these charges.
COCFA President Brad Reynolds said the union and school have maintained a good working relationship and COCFA/CTA is looking out for the best interest of the part-timers by trying to absorb them into their union.
COC Vice President Philip Hartley said this isn’t a matter of the school preferring one union over another; it just prefers one union.
“If roles had been reversed and AFT represented the full-timers and CTA wanted to come in and represent (the part-timers), we would have made the same decisions,” Hartley said.
Hartley said the decision to file an appeal is the college exercising its right. He added the school’s actions have been on the advice of PERB.
“PERB has a presumptive bias that, given a choice it would prefer a district deal with a single unit,” Hartley said. “Based on this, COC believes this as well.”
COCFA/CTA sent a letter to part-timers in November 2001 informing the adjunct faculty they would be represented by them. The union was advised by the school after being advised by PERB it was OK to absorb the part-timers into COCFA/CTA. Their reasoning for wanting to represent the part-timers, as stated in the letter, was: “We feel it is in our best interest to have one union representing the entire faculty.”
The part-timers say COCFA/CTA had no interest in representing them until October 2001, when the drive to make AFT their union began.
Linda Cushing , AFT national representative and director of the campaign for COC’s part-timers, said this appeal is evidence the school will not remain neutral.
“The irony of all this is that they’ve (COC) illegally interfered with the part-timers being able to find their own union, and by going to the court of appeals they continue to interfere with the part-timers seeking their own election,” Cushing said.
The part-timers have said the school is dragging the process along so some of them can leave the school, rendering their movement less powerful.
Reynolds said literature sent out to part-timers by AFT has presented COCFA/CTA and the college as one entity and has been misleading. He said his union would work hard at the negotiating table for the adjunct faculty.
But Reynolds said one mistake — before he became COCFA/CTA president — may have caused this squabble.
“What should have happened two years ago was that the COCFA should have called for an election instead of saying it would represent the part-timers,” Reynolds said.
Since that decision, legal challenges have continued and will until at least 2004, those involved say.
Cushing and some part-timers have gone as far as to accuse COC of cutting teachers’ classes for their involvement in the situation.
“Department chairs who are not part of our union, they’re part of their union, have been told in the past to cut certain leaders of our faculty group’s classes, and have admitted that they were told to do this by the administration,” Cushing said.
History instructor Michael Ward, president of Part Time Faculty United-AFT at COC — the group seeking representation by AFT — said he had classes taken away, then restored. Ward said his classes were restored a week after he filed an unfair labor practice.
Hartley said the allegations are untrue. He said the state budget crisis made cutting classes a possibility, but classes published in the Fall 2002 and Spring 2003 catalog were not cut. Teachers were advised of the possibilities before the schedules were finalized, but Hartley said in the end COC was able to save classes instead of cut them.
“The classes were never taken away so there was nothing to restore,” Hartley said.
Ward said he is willing to have a ballot with AFT and COCFA/CTA on it, and he, like Reynolds, believes this situation could have been avoided if the full-timers’ union held an election instead of absorbing the part-timers into their union — a move he called “arrogant.”
“If they would have had the election two years ago, I’m sure we (the part-timers) would have chosen CTA,” Ward said.
Ward added AFT has worked hard to gain the support of part-timers and in order for COCFA/CTA to be on the ballot, he expects the same from them. That expectation is COCFA/CTA getting a majority of the part-timers to sign authorization cards to get them on the ballot, like AFT did.
Cushing said the appeal could be heard anytime between now and September, but said the fight won’t be over once that decision is made. She said she thinks the college will continue a fight to bring the part-timers in with COCFA/CTA. But she said the AFT won’t give up either.
“We’re not doing this because we want to fight CTA and the administration. We want to provide a deal for them that would allow the part-timers to organize,” Cushing said. “We didn’t really expect this kind of fight, but now that we’re in it, we’re not going to abandon these people.”
Reynolds and Ward agree that a solution would be an election with both unions on the ballot, but at this point, it’s up for the courts to decide the course this conflict will ultimately take.
