Santa Clarita officials were downright giddy as the word spread Wednesday about Browning Ferris Industries’ donation of 400 acres in Elsmere Canyon to the county of Los Angeles as permanent open space.
Some were a tad less enthusiastic about the “other” 400 acres on the south side of Elsmere which BFI offered as a bargaining chip in exchange for exclusive trash-hauling rights in Santa Clarita.
We’ll opine about the trash franchise bids another time. Today our discussion concerns the 400 acres in the heart of a pristine canyon where the company had planned to build a landfill.
The fate of Elsmere Canyon has been a polarizing subject in Santa Clarita ever since the city was formed in 1987. It was in that same year that then-owner BKK Corp. filed for a permit to turn the unspoiled canyon, with all of its trees and waterfalls and endangered species, into the world’s largest trash dump.
The issue grew legs in 1989 when the Santa Clarita City Council started strategizing its fight to block the landfill. Several political neophytes, notably Jill Klajic and Marsha McLean, accused the council of vacillating. They seized the reins of public opinion, trumpeting the disastrous effects the landfill would have on the community — rightly so — and ultimately riding that horse all the way to a City Council seat — Klajic in 1990, McLean in 2002.
Along the way the effort collected an important ally in the form of Howard “Buck” McKeon, Santa Clarita’s first mayor and now a member of Congress. In 1996 McKeon on the GOP-controlled House side and U.S. Sen. Barbara Boxer on the Democratic-controlled Senate side pushed through federal legislation stymieing BKK’s plans.
The initial proposal for a 190-million-ton landfill counted on an exchange of acreage between BKK and the U.S. government. Trash would fill the part of Elsmere Canyon the company already owned, as well as adjacent acreage in the U.S. forest. BKK would get the forest land in exchange for property it didn’t need for the dump.
With BKK’s proposal in mind, McKeon’s and Boxer’s legislation prohibited the exchange of any federal land for the purpose of siting a landfill.
Thwarted, BKK regrouped and sold its property to waste giant Browning Ferris Industries, owner-operator of the nearby Sunshine Canyon Landfill.
Los Angeles County, meanwhile, kept Elsmere Canyon on its short list of potential landfill sites, and the threat of a smaller BFI dump in Elsmere lingered.
But BFI remained focused on its primary goal — the expansion of its existing landfill in Sunshine Canyon above Granada Hills, west of the Interstate 5-Route 14 split. To BFI, Elsmere Canyon was merely a pawn on a giant chess board where the opposing queen was the North Valley Coalition.
These San Fernando Valley homeowners had been fighting BFI for years with some success. In 1991 the city of Los Angeles shut down BFI’s 205-acre dump inside city limits, leaving the county in the lurch for landfill capacity. The County Board of Supervisors responded by approving a slightly larger BFI dump just over the city-county line in the unincorporated area.
But the new Sunshine dump didn’t solve the county’s problems. City trash kept coming to the now-county landfill, and county sanitation district officials clamored for more space. BFI filed for permits to reopen its original city-side dump, and in 1999, over the homeowners’s vehement protests, then-mayor Richard Riordan and the Los Angeles City Council acquiesced.
The decision played right into the hands of the San Fernando Valley’s would-be secessionists.
That move failed, but new Los Angeles Mayor James Hahn campaigned with a pledge to fight Sunshine’s expansion. He gave it a shot, but when BFI’s plan came up for the necessary state board approval 11 days ago, it was too little too late. The former Los Angeles City Council had approved it, the county sanitation districts wanted it, and county planners were threatening to forbid Los Angeles city trash from being dumped in BFI’s county landfill as long as Hahn objected to BFI reopening its landfill on the city side.
On May 12 the state waste board OK’d BFI’s expansion plan. By 4:30 p.m. on May 20, BFI and county Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich had dotted the i’s and crossed the t’s on BFI’s donation of 400 acres in Elsmere Canyon to Los Angeles County as a permanent open-space preserve.
The next move? Later this year you can expect BFI’s application to expand its 215-acre county landfill to come up for county approval. This would enable BFI to close the geographical gap between its city and county Sunshine landfills, combining them to form the second-largest landfill in the nation.
Those landfill operators are nothing if not clever negotiators.
