ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

For trash, devil is in the details — and elsewhere

Which devil do you choose?

The one you know? The one trying to bribe you? The one who lied to you?

It’s clear there are no Boy Scouts in the waste hauling business. It is an endeavor in which political savvy and a killer instinct serve an individual well. We’ve learned that much in dealing with the city’s trash hauling contract issues over the past two years. That’s how long it has been since The Signal first published a story saying a rival hauler said it could offer a lower trash rate — and give the city coveted property in Elsmere Canyon — in exchange for a long-term hauling contract.

The City Council initially voted to stay loyal to the existing haulers — Waste Management Inc. and Consolidated Disposal Service, both of which are subsidiaries of massive national companies. However, after The Signal reported the city was failing to meet the state’s waste diversion requirements — and the city’s trash rates were among the highest in Southern California, due in part to a rate calculated on an inflated figure for hauler dumping costs — the council decided to open the franchise to competitive bidding.

It was a long haul, politically. Much figurative blood was shed, and this newspaper took a great deal of heat for its stance in favor of going out to bid. Many community leaders, then and now, have strongly advocated a continuation of the status quo, largely out of personal loyalty to Waste Management, which has been a good corporate citizen in town, contributing to numerous local charities.

Despite that, we argued — then and now — that a competitive bid process is the only way to ensure the city is performing its fiduciary duty to local citizens, obtaining the best possible combination of service and price.

If you’ll pardon a bit of chest-thumping on our part, we feel vindicated by the proposals submitted to the city this week from six haulers. The point is proven: Competitive bidding will save Santa Clarita taxpayers tens of millions of dollars over the next decade.

Waste Management Inc., which serves about 85 percent of the city under the existing franchise, is the low bidder, with a proposed residential rate of $14.75 per month. This, despite the fact that WMI told the council two years ago it was economically impossible to go lower than $22.13 per month.

That was not true.

At first blush, WMI’s bid seems most attractive, and we know the company has a record of providing good service to customers. But we also know the company has a poor record when it comes to waste diversion — and WMI goes so far as to say in its bid that the city’s demands on that point aren’t feasible. So before the council considers granting the contract to WMI, council members must investigate and arrive at an answer to the question: “If WMI can’t meet the waste diversion requirements at $22.13 per month, how can it possibly do so at $14.75?”

Is $14.75 a credible offer for service that meets the city’s demands? The question must be asked and answered.

If that proposal is indeed credible, consider the savings for local taxpayers. It’s more than just the $7.38 per month you would save. It’s $7.38 multiplied by 12 months per year, multiplied by 33,627 single-family households, multiplied by the 10-year term of the deal.

That’s $29.78 million, without even taking into account condos and apartments. One might say that’s how much “extra” we’ve paid for the past decade. Regardless, we’d only get the price cut as a result of having gone to competitive bidding.

Even if you take one of the “higher” bids, the math is still staggering: If the residential rate ends up at, say $18, Santa Clarita single-family homeowners collectively would save $16.67 million over the life of the contract.

Another perceived front runner is Browning Ferris Industries, the company that kick-started the debate more than two years ago with its hint that Elsmere Canyon could be offered as a carrot for the trash contract.

It’s no surprise that BFI is offering up Elsmere now, and there are intriguing political undercurrents. BFI doesn’t seem to balk at the waste diversion demands, but its proposed rate of $17.80 is more than $3 per month more than WMI’s. That fact cannot be ignored. Nor, apparently, can the Elsmere aspect of the offer. It will make for interesting discussion on the council dais.

Sandwiched between WFI and BMI is Burrtec Waste Industries, at $16.46 per month. Burrtec proposes to build a materials recovery facility to help ensure that waste diversion goals are met. It appears Burrtec should at least be viewed as a contender.

Consolidated, which has 15 percent of the franchise, came in at $18.29 — a significant drop from the current rate, yet only fourth-lowest. But don’t count them out just yet.

Crown Disposal Co. offered an $18.76 residential rate, and E.J. Harrison & Sons is a distant sixth at $25.25. We’ll go so far as to say E.J. Harrison & Sons is out of the running. We didn’t go through two years of debate to pay more for trash service.

Our position on this has been nothing if not consistent: The City Council is obligated to choose the best possible combination of price and service — and that includes meeting the state’s waste reduction requirements.

It is still early in the process. There are many issues to evolve, questions to address, including the not-so-small matter of the commercial franchise, which can be granted with the residential or given to a different hauler.

Whatever the choice, we hope the council reads every syllable of those six proposals, listens to its consultants and staff, asks the tough questions and makes the most informed decision possible, based not on personal loyalty or, conversely, hard feelings, but on getting the best service at the best price.

With, of course, the full realization that, no matter who is chosen, we’re not exactly dealing with Boy Scouts.

← Back to 2003

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-vs:2532.
System
ViewStory pages (/News/ViewStory.asp)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,003 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
viewstory:font_body
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [Editorial from The Signal; The Newspaper's Opinion]
  • text:valley_names [3 distinct/8 mentions: Santa Clarita, City Council, Elsmere]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 5, national 0