Santa Clarita has gotten a lot of attention this year in the lofty legislative halls of Sacramento. While we’re not privy to the lawmakers’ closed-door conversations, it’s difficult to imagine that the buzz is putting our fair municipality in a good light. In fact, it’s likely we’ve been the butt of more than a few jokes.
That’s because we’re the “test city” for diaper recycling. The state invested $250,000 in our pilot program and put us under their microscope.
The last time we garnered this kind of attention in the state capitol was when the Santa Clarita City Council tried to put virtually the entire city under redevelopment after the 1994 earthquake. The tax-grabbing scheme elicited guffaws all the way from Sacramento to downtown Los Angeles, where a court ultimately shot it down.
Now we’re back at the center of controversy, and until last week it seemed that if all goes as promised with our conversion of soiled personal items into useful household products, the state would impose a quarter-cent tax on those items at the grocery store to finance diaper recycling programs throughout California.
But singling out a product for a special tax is a high-stakes proposition. The makers of Luvs, Huggies and Pampers reacted predictably, and some conservative syndicated columnists turned up the heat by claiming, first, that Santa Clarita’s pilot program failed; second, that women would unfairly bear the brunt of the tax, since there are more unwed mothers than fathers who buy diapers; and third, that the tax would benefit a single company — Knowaste, the only manufacturer of diaper recycling equipment.
Evidently the pressure was sufficient, because late last week Sen. Don Perata, the Oakland Democrat who was sponsoring the quarter-cent tax proposal, decided to withdraw it.
Perata’s stated reason was that it wasn’t the right time, what with California’s monumental budget deficit, to impose a new tax for a service the state isn’t already providing.
We’d surmise that there’s more behind Perata’s decision, but the upshot is that the diaper tax is dead — at least this year.
In the meantime the Santa Clarita City Council has voted to extend its “diaper study” for another three months, saying the results for the last six months were inconclusive because of unforeseen problems with the Knowaste machine — which the city purchased for half a million dollars ($250,000 from the state and $250,000 of the city’s own money).
Clearly the city needs to step up its overall recycling efforts in order to comply with the state law requiring municipalities to divert 50 percent of their waste from landfills. That’s why the city included diaper recycling in its request for proposals from the trash companies.
But by even the most generous estimates, diapers make up less than half of 1 percent of our waste stream.
Every little bit helps, but at the end of this three-month “extension” we’ll expect the city to measure the success of the program — meager though the data may be — and reevaluate whether the cost justifies the implementation of citywide diaper recycling.
City officials will need to remember that the state won’t be paying for it, now that the quarter-cent diaper surcharge is history, and they’ll have to do some hard selling if they want residents to bear the burden alone.
