And now they wait again, fingers crossed, on the edge of their seats. You could practically feel the cautious but noticeable sigh of relief emanating from The Newhall Land and Farming Co. building down the street on Tuesday, when the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors gave the green light to the company’s Newhall Ranch project — the single largest housing project ever approved in Los Angeles County history.
We doubt too many champagne corks were popping, though. The supervisors’ approval was just the latest episode in a long and rocky road to getting the project off the ground. Unlike a “routine” development decision, this time the supervisors don’t have the last word.
That’s because the county of Ventura and a pack of environmental organizations successfully sued Los Angeles County the last time the supervisors approved the project in 1999.
The case went to trial — held in the neutral territory of Kern County to deter favoritism toward the opposing counties — and ultimately the plaintiffs convinced the judge to put the project on hold.
The judge ruled that Los Angeles County violated its own planning policies in six specific instances when the supervisors gave Newhall Ranch the nod. The judge held that the environmental documents didn’t adequately address the way the project would affect traffic in Ventura County, the migration of wildlife, the biota of the Santa Clara River, the impacts of a water reclamation plant — and most challenging of all, the adequacy of the water supply over the 30-year life of the project.
There were some interesting twists and turns along the way, as Newhall Land endeavored to rectify all of the deficiencies and bring back its revised plans for the supervisors’ re-approval.
Environmental groups attacked the project from every imaginable angle, even suing the valley’s state water wholesaler on grounds that it overstated water availability in its urban water management plan. Nobody had ever sued a public agency over its urban water management plan before.
Meanwhile, the state Legislature passed new bills requiring local governments to take even more stringent steps to verify water availability for large development projects.
There were other lawsuits, one of the more significant involving an endangered flower that Newhall Land discovered on its Newhall Ranch property in 2000, after the supervisors’ initial approval.
Accused by the California Department of Fish and Game of knowingly destroying the species by grading without a permit, Newhall Land ultimately settled the lawsuit in February, agreeing to set aside 64 acres for the spineflower that were otherwise slated for development.
Newhall Land overcame what was perhaps its biggest hurdle in December when it announced that it had struck a deal to purchase water each year from a private, family-owned farming company in the San Joaquin Valley, on top of other steps the company took to boost the local water supply.
And now it comes down to this. Now, three years after the judge’s decision, four years after the supervisors’ initial approval, nine years after the project was formally proposed, this same judge will decide whether Newhall Land and the county of Los Angeles have done enough.
In one aisle of the judge’s Bakersfield courtroom you’ll have members of the environmental community, who have proven that you can indeed fight city hall — or the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors — if you’re diligent enough. They deserve the credit or blame for dealing Newhall Land a four-year setback in its plans, actually more, and for taking a bite out of the company’s anticipated earnings.
In the other aisle you’ll have the attorneys for a New York Stock Exchange-listed company that has put all of its corporate muscle into sealing every imaginable loophole and leaving the judge with no legal basis for dissent.
On the bench you’ll have a single human being who will be charged with making a decision that will affect every man, woman and child in the Santa Clarita Valley, potentially for decades to come. Potentially forever.
That’s an awesome responsibility, and it’s a mighty big gavel for one individual to wield.
