ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Taxpayers are winners in bidding for city trash deal

There’s only one conclusion that can yet be drawn from the proposals six trash haulers have submitted for the new 10-year city trash hauling contract:

The taxpayers win.

The reason is the same one this newspaper has cited for two years. Citizens have been forced to overpay for trash service since the city of Santa Clarita took away our right to choose our own hauler and created franchises a decade ago.

Depending upon which numbers we end up with, you’ve been overpaying to the tune of $4 to $7 per month. That may not sound like a lot, but when you multiply it by tens of thousands of households, it’s millions of dollars unnecessarily leaving the Santa Clarita Valley’s economy.

Who’s to blame for that?

If nothing else, in this case, it appears the haulers were able to fleece us because our government let them do it. Thankfully, that’s no longer the case.

You pay $22.13 per month.

The low bid for the new contract is $14.75 — and that low bid came from the biggest local hauler, which told your City Council two years ago that it was not economically feasible to drop the rate.

Funny how a little competition will change a company’s tune.

That particular little white lie — or, whopper, if you choose — was told by Karl McCarthy, who was then the general manager of Blue Barrel, the local subsidiary of the trash giant, Waste Management Inc. He’s also the one who told your City Council that WMI was meeting and exceeding state waste diversion requirements in Santa Clarita, which later proved not to be true.

Insiders will tell you WMI is perfectly willing to hang McCarthy out to dry for it all. In any case, you’ll hardly ever see McCarthy around town anymore. WMI essentially banished him to Palmdale.

McCarthy is a likable guy, and he was generous with WMI’s donations to local charities — earning him and the company a great deal of favor with local movers and shakers. That’s what made it so difficult to move the city toward an open bid process, despite mounting problems with waste diversion statistics and very clear evidence that local trash rates were based on inflated hauler costs, thus creating inflated rates.

Now, the local front man for WMI is Chris Fall, and, like McCarthy, he’s a very likable guy. But they are, quite obviously to anyone who has known them both, two very different people. Regardless, what we all have to remember is that we are dealing with a large company, not just one person, no matter how much we like him.

A few months back I told Chris that, if all other things were equal, I could support Blue Barrel getting the contract if they were, say, within a buck of the low bidder’s rate. My rationale was that local residents and businesses have been happy with the service provided by WMI, and the company has been a good corporate citizen in Santa Clarita — that little lie about the feasibility of a rate cut notwithstanding.

Suffice to say, they’re within a buck of the low bid. They are the low bidder.

However, the one thing I’m not yet sure about is that “all other things being equal” portion of the equation.

Each hauler listed “exceptions” to the city’s request for proposals — items that they would have a problem with, or would wish to negotiate further. For the most part, those “exceptions” were minor items — housekeeping things like insurance questions. Blue Barrel, however, is the only top contender that said the city’s waste diversion demands are unrealistic.

In other words, at least to a lay person like me, it seems as if the other haulers turned in bids designed to meet the city’s waste diversion demands. WMI didn’t.

Perhaps that can be addressed as this process moves forward. Perhaps WMI is right — maybe the demands are unrealistic. Heaven knows, Santa Clarita and the local haulers — WMI and Consolidated Disposal — have been unable to meet state waste reduction requirements while charging $22.13 per month. It’s counterintuitive to believe WMI could do it for $14.75.

Still, that’s an issue that needs to be addressed as the City Council moves forward. Other items remain, too.

There is, for example, the proposal by Browning Ferris Industries to throw in 400 acres of coveted land in Elsmere Canyon, giving Santa Clarita a roadblock for a possible landfill in the canyon, which the community would rather see preserved.

I’ve always thought the contract should be awarded based on the best combination of service and price, and that things like 400-acre carrots shouldn’t enter the mix.

But these are high stakes. I admit to mixed feelings on it. If nothing else, the city would have to do the math and figure out how much that 400 acres would cost. Suppose our rates are $3.05 per month higher if we go with BFI than with WMI. That’s $24 per year, times 33,627 single-family households, for 10 years. (In these sorts of calculations, for rough numbers, I don’t factor in multi-family units, whose rates are calculated differently; I am also omitting the commercial portion of the contract, which will be examined in more depth here as we digest the bids...)

So. Oversimplifying it — admittedly, by a lot — that would mean 400 acres of Elsmere would cost taxpayers a minimum of $12.3 million, or $30,768 per acre.

The property is probably worth that much in political capital. But still. It’s basically a tax on you and me to buy the land. And, as we said in last Sunday’s editorial, it presents us with a choice between the hauler who lied to us and the one trying to bribe us.

Or, someone else. Fontana-based Burrtec had the second lowest bid and, by some accounts, one of the more attractive proposals. And there’s Consolidated, which serves 15 percent of the city and shouldn’t be casually dismissed.

Most people, though, seem to view it as a two-horse race. That may be right, or not — but if you ask those who are watching, they’re talking about WMI and BFI.

The vote-counting is already under way among council watchers. Councilman Frank Ferry has long been a steadfast supporter of WMI. And Councilwoman Marsha McLean got elected last year in large part due to campaign donations by WMI. Conversely, it’s no big secret that there’s no love lost between WMI and Councilwoman Laurene Weste. I just hope all five council members ask the questions they should ask, and make an intelligent, well-informed choice.

Who am I pulling for? I don’t know yet. If all other things are equal, I’d stand by what I told Chris Fall, and support WMI — perhaps holding my nose while doing so, considering the extra millions that went to WMI over the years thanks to the country-bumpkin way Santa Clarita handled the contract before finally being dragged into putting it out to bid.

Problem is, I don’t know if all other things are equal. I think the responsible thing is to reserve judgment until I can digest the information, get more answers and form a more informed opinion.

It’s an interesting choice, but whichever hauler wins, the one thing beyond question is that Santa Clarita residents will save millions. With all due respect to the community leaders who wanted to give a contract renewal to WMI on nothing more than blind faith and loyalty, the bids prove this newspaper was right two years ago when it started calling for a bid process — in the face of severe and influential opposition from local movers and shakers.

Mayor Cameron Smyth and Councilwoman Weste deserve much of the credit for making it happen. They pushed the issue at the council level, and Councilman Bob Kellar did the right thing last year when he cast the swing vote to send the contract out to bid.

In that respect, it doesn’t much matter to me whether WMI or BFI or one of the other top bidders gets the right to haul our trash. At least we’ll know our government, for the first time, made a sincere effort to try to get the best deal for taxpayers.

That’s all we ever wanted.

Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.

← Back to 2003

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-vs:2555.
System
ViewStory pages (/News/ViewStory.asp)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,391 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
viewstory:font_body
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [managing editor]
  • text:valley_names [3 distinct/13 mentions: Santa Clarita, City Council, Elsmere]
  • text:valley_elected_official “Cameron Smyth”
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 6, national 0