Despite its claim that Santa Clarita's goal to reduce its waste stream by 75 percent is unrealistic, Blue Barrel Disposal officials said they are confident their company's proposal conforms with the city's demands.
In its proposal for the city's trash contracts, Blue Barrel makes an "exception" to the city's requirement for 50-percent waste reduction by the second calendar quarter of the new contract.
"The proposed requirements are unworkable and may even be impossible to meet," the company states in its bid for the city's exclusive residential trash franchise.
The city's request for proposals (RFP) calls for an initial goal of 50 percent, "while working toward an overall diversion rate of 75 percent."
Blue Barrel Manager Chris Fall said he doesn't feel his company's proposal is out of bounds.
"I think everybody should have goals," he said. "We'll do everything we can to meet those.
"Is (75 percent) impossible? No. Difficult? Yes," Fall said. "If there's a will, there's a way, and we've got the will."
Fall said Blue Barrel's exception was made to point out that the city's commercial and residential waste that's collected by the contract hauler is just 60 percent of city's total trash; the remaining 40 percent is managed by roll-off companies.
City officials were unable to verify the numbers Friday.
"We're very confident we can work out the legal and technical language," Fall said. "Again, the whole goal is to meet the state law."
Assembly Bill 939 requires municipalities to divert 50 percent of their waste from landfills.
Fall said education and outreach over the last year have helped Blue Barrel's dumping totals go down and diversion numbers go up.
"Our service has never been in question, and that's what the City Council was looking for -- the best service at the best rate," Fall said. Blue Barrel offered the lowest residential trash rate at $14.75 per month.
But the other hauling companies that are vying for the city contract take exception to Blue Barrel's exception. They claim that 75-percent diversion is attainable.
"We believe the city put forth a very comprehensive RFP that was very thoughtfully spelled out as to what was requested," said Matt Terrell, general manager of Consolidated Disposal Service, which now hauls 15 percent of the city's trash under the existing contract. "I don't believe (75 percent) is impossible. I believe it's very aggressive. It will take a certain lengthy time period to achieve that."
Terrell said with a good-faith effort and public education, the city's diversion goals are "doable."
Burrtec Waste Industries Vice President Eric Herbert said he didn't think anyone knows for sure whether they'd be able to meet 75 percent.
"With the current programs, they're clearly not," he said. "Residents are doing a good job (recycling), but they could do a better job. They can do 75 percent."
"It's aggressive, but if the hauler is willing to go the extra mile, you can expect better than 50 percent," said Greg Loughnane, Los Angeles district manager for Browning Ferris Industries. "Clearly, if you look at some of the proposals, (other haulers) have their own ideas."
In its proposal, Crown Disposal Co. states that it has "proposed residential and commercial services that will exceed the city's minimum diversion requirements in the first year of operation."
"(Achieving 75 percent) is not going to be easy for everybody," Crown Sales Manager Tom Ybarra said.
Crown started hauling trash in San Fernando under a new contract in November, and has increased that city's diversion rate from 24 percent to more than 56 percent in the first six months of service, according to officials from Crown and the city of San Fernando.
Crown took over San Fernando's contracts from Blue Barrel's parent company, Waste Management Inc.
Ybarra said he believes some of the proposals are non-responsive to the city's RFP.
"The RFP asks not to deviate or else they'll be disqualified," Ybarra said.
"A couple of the proposals are way out in left field. We hope the city notices that and takes appropriate action."
City officials say they are unsure how they will handle proposals that appear non-responsive to the city's requests.
Jill Fosselman, assistant to the city manager, said the city is still evaluating the proposals, including the exceptions.
"Part of the process is to clarify things that seem unclear, and to understand what the exceptions are asking for," she said.
Of Blue Barrel's claim that the city's goals are unworkable, Fosselman said, "That's an exception. We're evaluating it."
She said she could not comment on whether the city's 75-percent diversion request was impossible.
However, the city stated in its original RFP that it discourages, and may disqualify, proposals that substantially deviate.
"The city reserves the right to reject all proposals, disqualify proposals as non-responsive, waive non-material deviations from the RFP, and determine whether proposers are qualified," the RFP states. "Proposals must comply fully with the requirements detailed in this RFP."
Fosselman said the evaluation criteria as outlined in the RFP are based on general experience, good references, public education, diversion track record, legitimacy of proposed programs, financial reserves;,whether the hauler can substantiate landfill capacity, cost, the nature of any proposed exceptions, the city's willingness to accept the exceptions, and the extent to which the City Council's specific proposal requests are met.
Within their proposals, Blue Barrel and Burrtec outlined plans to build a materials recovery facility (MRF) in Santa Clarita to help boost the city's diversion numbers.
Herbert said Burrtec has responded to the city's request for guaranteed landfill space with a landfill in Orange County, in addition to plans for an MRF in Santa Clarita.
He said he is confident Burrtec would be able to construct the facility in time to take over the city's services. "Fortunately the city has started the process early enough that there's still opportunity."
Burrtec has built 12 such facilities in Southern California, and Herbert said he believes the Santa Clarita community would embrace having an MRF for its environmental benefits.
"I don't see opposition. I see a lot of support," he said. "It's not a landfill."
Herbert said he believes it's a bonus not to be tied to a local landfill, and that by building an MRF, the city will have more control over its recycling in the long run.
"You've still got to do the recycling," he said. "You can't just take it to the landfill and say you're recycling it."
