Robert Lee had never seen a story take off quite like this one.
The superintendent of the William S. Hart Union High School District said the national media attention over an advertisement placed in the La Mesa Junior High School yearbook was like a butterfly that flaps its wings in Africa, and by the time the wind from the wings reaches South Carolina it’s a full-blown hurricane.
Fourteen-year-old Brytini Benjamin stepped up to the microphone at Wednesday’s school board meeting and introduced herself.
“I am your butterfly,” she said.
In a story that broke last week in The Signal, Benjamin made national news Wednesday when she was interviewed by Keith Olbermann on MSNBC about her concern over an ad placed in her junior high school yearbook by the National Rifle Association.
Benjamin attended the Hart district board meeting that evening to request a new policy outlining what ads are appropriate for yearbooks.
She was met by silence from school board members.
Both Benjamin and her mother, Kim, weren’t quite sure what to expect from the board, but said they learned a lot about politics.
“Brytini feels so good about what she has done,” Kim said. “Most people I talk to said they can’t believe (the school district doesn’t) see the problem.”
School board policy states any citizen may address the board on items of interest to the public that are within the jurisdiction of the board, but no action will be taken on any item not appearing on the agenda, and the board president may limit discussion on any item.
The Hart board typically thanks members of the audience who come forward to speak, and has even commented on issues, but it opted not to with Benjamin.
Board President Phil Ellis said he didn’t see any reason to comment.
“I prefer not to engage in conversation if I don’t have to,” Ellis said. “I think this issue has gotten blown out of proportion, more than it should be. That’s one of the reasons I didn’t want to comment on it. Something that’s made national wires, it’s obviously been blown out of proportion.”
Ellis said he wasn’t even sure if there was a policy on yearbook ads.
“We can have policies on everything and it gets a little absurd. If I thought the NRA’s purpose was to push guns, then I think it would be wrong,” he said.
Board member Steve Sturgeon said he couldn’t directly comment on the ad since he hasn’t seen a copy of it, but he knows the ad was placed by the grandfather of a La Mesa student.
“I appreciate that (Benjamin) came forward with her suggestion to review our policies,” Sturgeon said. “I (also) believe the (NRA) ad garnered more attention than it was the intent of the person who placed the ad.”
Benjamin told Olbermann she thought it was OK for the ad to quote the Second-Amendment right to bear arms, but did not think it was appropriate for there to be a toll-free number to join the NRA.
Kim Benjamin said her family has been inundated with requests for interviews.
“Brytini’s summer school classes start Monday and she’s in flag camp. She saw an opportunity to make a change when she brought this to (the school board’s) and the public’s attention,” she said. “She’s been responsible and a class act through all of this.”
Kim said she plans to write to the principal at Columbine, the high school in Colorado where a dozen students and a teacher were gunned down in 1999, to solicit his opinion of the Hart district’s position.
“He might tell them you can’t ignore this,” she said.
Brytini said she didn’t know if the board will act on her request.
“There is a difference between listening and hearing,” she said. “The ball’s in motion. If people are interested and feeling strongly about it like I do, they’ll do something. I can’t do it all myself.”
She said she didn’t want to embarrass the school district, but also didn’t want the issue to be ignored.
“I believe change only happens when butterflies flap their wings,” she told the board.
