Squeeze the turnip, and when it looks like it’s bleeding to death, squeeze it some more.
That, apparently, is the state of California’s approach to balancing its budget, whose wreckage is rooted in Sacramento’s mishandling of the energy “crisis” two summers ago.
Prosperity may only trickle down, but devastation drowns local governments in a sea of red ink.
Gargantuan Los Angeles County is in dire straits, as seen locally with the threatened closures of the Newhall Library, Placerita Canyon Nature Center and Castaic Lake Recreation Area.
Even Santa Clarita, our own fiscally conservative enclave where public officials generally underestimate revenues and overestimate expenditures to the point where they wind up with a mid-year surplus, is feeling the pinch.
City officials are trimming all department budgets, delaying planned expenditures, eliminating grant programs and considering new fees just to even the keel and add a single patrol deputy this year.
And that may not be the last of it. There’s a move afoot in Sacramento that could drop the budget ax on a segment of the population that can least afford it.
As noted in this column in January, Gov. Gray Davis is threatening to rob California redevelopment agencies of their low-cost housing revenues. Although it hasn’t happened yet, sadly the plan is still alive.
Redevelopment agencies, like the one Santa Clarita is using to eliminate blight in downtown Newhall, are required by law to set aside 20 percent of their revenues to build and improve housing for moderate and low-income residents.
Santa Clarita’s redevelopment agency has only recently started to generate tax-increment revenues, so the local housing fund isn’t very big yet. There’s only about $350,000 to $400,000 in the kitty — not enough to start building affordable housing in East Newhall or to incentivize absentee landlords to renovate.
But the agency’s housing fund will grow over time, and if the city is resolute, it will be able to leverage the funds to upgrade Newhall’s impoverished neighborhoods and improve the quality of life for the people who live there.
The city has already shown its concern, having used state block-grant funds to add curbs, gutters and sidewalks where none existed before.
Those block-grant funds are likely to be in shorter supply now, but the city can take some consolation in knowing its redevelopment agency will be able to pay for affordable housing in the long run.
Unless the governor raids the fund. And the word is, it’s not expected to be a one-time grab, but rather a 15-year shift.
The proposed tax-grab hearkens back to 1992, when Gov. Pete Wilson “shifted” money from city and county governments to meet the mandate of Proposition 98, the 1988 ballot measure that guarantees school funding.
That’s what Gov. Davis would be doing with the redevelopment housing money: adding it to the Educational Revenue Augmentation Fund.
With the possible exception of public safely, the idea that education funding is of paramount importance would invite little dissent. But taking housing dollars from redevelopment agencies is simply a way for “big government” to shirk its fiscal responsibilities at the expense of “small government.”
If the state had the gumption to cut its own fat by another $250 million this year and $50 million each year after that — the amount that would be taken from redevelopment agencies statewide — it wouldn’t have to raid a bank account that cities use to help the urban poor, in order to finance classrooms.
You probably haven’t heard much outcry about this, for good reason. Redevelopment agencies are easy targets, and the urban poor don’t have many high-priced lobbyists to do their fighting for them.
“Politically, redevelopment agencies have not been able to exercise the clout in Sacramento that other constituencies have, such as public employee unions or teachers,” Howard Fine writes in the California Journal.
Redevelopment agencies garner little sympathy among state lawmakers, Fine notes, because there were abuses in the past. Agencies formed in the 1970s and ‘80s sometimes made bad mistakes, and some let their housing funds languish.
But that’s not the case in Newhall, where redevelopment was imposed after the laws were tightened in 1993, and where redevelopment officials are eager for the housing fund to expand so they can improve the housing stock.
“Redevelopment agencies now fund the building of some 16,000 affordable housing units per year in California, the largest single source of funding for affordable housing,” Fine writes.
That’s what makes the governor’s proposal all the more nonsensical. Davis himself has lamented that California isn’t keeping up with its need to build affordable housing.
So, is there anything the city can do now to avoid losing its housing dollars for the next 15 years? Maybe. Davis supposedly has his eye on “unencumbered” housing dollars, meaning money that isn’t yet committed to a specific housing project. The city should encumber its housing dollars, and fast.
With the imminent departure of the city’s treasurer, Steve Stark, for a higher paying job in Santa Monica, figuring out how to commit the money should be a top priority for Stark’s interim replacement.
Hopefully the money can be earmarked for the sort of redevelopment project that defines many small American downtowns: multi-story buildings with quaint shops downstairs and residential units upstairs. Other city departments are already working on just such a plan.
Leon Worden is The Signal’s city editor. His commentary appears Wednesdays.
