City officials have recommended three solid waste haulers — Blue Barrel Disposal, Burrtec Waste Industries and Consolidated Disposal Service — to remain in the running for the city’s new residential and commercial trash franchises.
City Council members will vote Tuesday whether to approve the staff recommendation, which also includes an outline of the negotiation process and a request for an additional $50,000 to cover the negotiation costs.
If the recommendation is approved, the three ousted haulers — Browning Ferris Industries, Crown Disposal Co., and E.J. Harrison & Sons — will be eliminated from the city’s further consideration.
The decision to narrow down the field was based on a desire to “sort out the best value from the really good values,” said Jill Fosselman, assistant to the city manager.
The determining factor in selecting Blue Barrel, Burrtec and Consolidated was cost, she said. The three haulers proposed the lowest rates for both the residential and commercial contracts, based on rate revenues for the first year.
“They will offer to customers an 11 (percent) to 23 percent reduction in cost,” Fosselman said.
According to a report by the city’s consultant, Blue Barrel proposed the lowest rates, with a 27 percent rate reduction for residential service and a 9 percent reduction for commercial service. Burrtec would reduce residential rates by 20 percent and commercial rates by 5 percent. Consolidated offered a 13 percent reduction to the current residential rates, while the commercial rates would remain the same.
BFI, Crown and Harrison each would increase the cost for hauling commercial waste.
Harrison was the only hauler to raise rates overall, by about 49 percent, city statistics show.
“The proposals submitted by BFI and Crown are good overall proposals from experienced companies, but they do not appear to offer significant additional solid waste services to the city that would justify the additional costs compared to the proposals submitted by Blue Barrel, Burrtec and Consolidated,” states a letter from the city’s hired consultant Hilton Farnkopf & Hobson, LLC.
The city responded to BFI’s proposal to negotiate a land gift in coveted Elsmere Canyon by weighing the hauler’s proposed rates with and without the land. The land transfer would result in a higher residential rate, a city report states, and increases the annual cost of BFI’s proposal by $448,000 annually.
The consultant suggested the City Council determine “whether the value of the Elsmere Canyon land would merit including BFI in the next phase of evaluation.”
Blue Barrel offered the city a proposal that would implement the lower rates as early as January 2004 if the company is awarded both the residential and commercial contracts.
“We did not put any emphasis on the ‘Do It Now’ proposal,” Fosselman said. “In fact, we just kind of ignored it.”
City officials are evaluating the proposals only on terms specifically asked for in the city’s request for proposals, she said.
Fosselman said the reduced playing field will provide more of an incentive for the remaining haulers to remove their exceptions. Burrtec was the only hauler to make no exceptions to the city’s requests.
“We’re expecting that a lot of these exceptions will disappear,” Fosselman said. The city will meet privately with each of the three remaining haulers to negotiate the contracts and clarify exceptions, she added.
In its proposal to the city, Blue Barrel made exception to the city’s demands to maintain a 50-percent diversion rate, calling the request “unworkable and may even be impossible to meet.”
Officials decided to recommend keeping Blue Barrel as a finalist despite a statement in a letter to the city from its hired trash consultant that Blue Barrel’s exceptions “are potentially significant and cause for concern.”
“The city has no obligation to accept any of the exceptions,” Fosselman said.
Officials are also asking the council to approve a proposed timeline to follow for the negotiation process. City staff would present the final signed agreements to the council at a special study session August 19. The council would consider awarding the contracts a week later, on August 26.
The additional $50,000 requested in the staff recommendation is to cover the remaining costs to negotiate with three haulers, Fosselman said. The city had initially budgeted to negotiate terms of the contracts with just one hauler.
The cost for the proposal process will be reimbursed to the city by the hauler that is awarded the contract, according to a city report.
