How kind! How wonderful! How delightful! The citizens of the Santa Clarita Valley are being bribed — again — with their own money.
I think it is peachy-wonderful-keen that Los Angeles County Fifth District Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich is dipping into his “discretionary fund” cookie jar and pulling out $30,000 to keep the doors open of the Placerita Nature Center.
It is a wonderful gesture and much appreciated by everyone who loves nature and appreciates the fine work done by the volunteers and staff of the Nature Center.
However...
How much money is in this taxpayer-funded “discretionary fund?”
It seems I often hear of the supervisor’s “discretionary fund” bailing out this charity or helping with that charity or doing other “good” works.
There’s no question the supervisor’s “discretionary fund” has been used for uniformly outstanding purposes, benefits for the arts, rewards to capture murderers, support for parks, children and seniors. I don’t quibble on how the money has been spent.
However, I don’t mean to be cynical, but I do hope every citizen understands the supervisor’s “discretionary fund” is used for the purpose of buying the goodwill of the citizens of the district — and therefore votes — keeping Antonovich (and his supervisor cronies) in their cushy government jobs. (Term limits, anyone?)
I don’t think even Chicago’s Mayor Daley, the king of political patronage, could have invented a more insidious system.
Los Angeles County isn’t the only county in California with this kind of “Buy a Few Votes Petty Cash Fund.”
A Marin County Grand Jury looked into the practice in 2001. The Grand Jury issued a report that mirrors my concerns about the fund including the routine of disbursing county funds to organizations without the grants being subjected to the “normal budgeting approval process” and allowing “the County to circumvent the prohibition of gifts or contributions of public funds to organizations and entities without the requisite performance of comparable value-added services to the benefit of the County.”
In addition, the Grand Jury noted, “...creation of a system of disbursements which by the very nature of the process, gives rise to a real or perceived political patronage system beholden to members of the Board of Supervisors and its high level County personnel.”
Bingo! There is the crux of the matter... “a perceived political patronage system...”
The ghost of Mayor Daley lives on.
The Grand Jury had several recommendations to fix the system:
“Given the potential for political patronage abuse and the vagueness in interpretation of benefits being provided to the County noted in a number of the Agreement For Services arrangements with the recipients, the Grand Jury is of the opinion that continued existence of The Fund in its present form is unacceptable. The current Supervisors Discretionary Fund should be eliminated; or in the alternative The Fund should be broken out as a separate line item in the budget and subjected to the normal budgetary review process.
Further, if the existence of The Fund is continued, the Board of Supervisors should cause procedures to be adopted which:
n Allow all eligible organizations to participate in an application process that will ensure that all worthwhile organizations (both public and non-profit) have an opportunity to apply for moneys from The Fund;
n Provide for an accurate and detailed Agreement For Service to ensure that organizations or public entities receiving funds actually perform a meaningful service benefiting the citizens of Marin County;
n Assume responsibility to institute provisions for auditing and/or a follow-up procedure to assure that the services contracted for by the County in connection with these fund disbursements have been performed in accordance with their contractual obligations; and
n Provide a written communication accompanying each disbursement from The Fund stating that these are County funds and any acknowledgment by the recipient should reflect this fact.”
I think the Marin County Grand Jury was on to something. However, I don’t imagine the supervisors are going to freely give up their money-filled cookie jars.
I don’t know how much remains in the supervisor’s “petty cash” fund, but I’d like to put my application of a few “discretionary” projects of my own.
My list is very short, it is in not intended to disparage the good works the organizations that receive “discretionary” money do. However, it is a look at where money COULD go without the spotlight of an appropriate budgeting process. Mr. Supervisor, have you considered the “Mother’s Day Spa Relief Fund?” You want votes? That’s a sure-fire vote-getter from all the exhausted soccer moms. Not to mention “The ‘NO! Not a Summer Job!’ Welfare Grant” — a special program for teenagers which will allow the supervisors to buy their votes young.
Of course I’d also like some money to be deposited in the “Starving Journalists Beer and Nachos Trust.” The benefits of that would be obvious.
I’d also like Antonovich to contribute to tree-sitter John Quiqley’s legal defense fund. Quiqley is the subject of a harassment lawsuit from John Laing Homes despite being removed from the Pico Canyon oak tree he spent 72 days defending. Antonovich’s lack of leadership contributed to the entire “Old Glory” debacle, so therefore he should spring for the attorney fees.
To answer the question posed above: How much money is in Antonovich’s cookie jar? Here’s the payoff: The Los Angeles County Supervisors have voted to give each of the five supervisors a $3 million “discretionary fund” for 2003. Granted, the county budget is a behemoth $16.5 BILLION, but seeing $15 million of the taxpayer’s money stashed in a fund for the sole disbursement of a county supervisor seems reckless when many desperately needed programs are being slashed willy-nilly.
The purpose of this “fund” doesn’t seem all that “discreet” to me.
Michele E. Buttelman is the features editor of The Signal. She can be reached by e-mail at [email protected].
