I heard the fix was in about three weeks ago, approximately a week after six haulers submitted proposals for the city’s new trash contract.
The staff is going to narrow the field, I was told by a reliable source within City Hall.
The source said the staff would tell the City Council that three of the six haulers should be eliminated from the competition — Browning Ferris Industries, Crown Disposal and E.J. Harrison and Sons.
The council, of course, has the authority to reject the recommendation. But the recommendation would be made. This would happen despite the fact that everyone we talked to at the time claimed they had not yet spent sufficient time reviewing the six proposals to determine which ones were the most responsive to the city’s request for proposals (RFP).
The three that would be kept, my source said, would be local newcomer Burrtec, out of Fontana, and the two companies that currently share the contracts: Blue Barrel and Consolidated, both subsidiaries of national companies.
This week, my source proved prescient, as the city staff did just that.
I normally don’t like to use sources without divulging their names. I usually tell sources I can’t use their information unless they’re willing to attach their names to it. You won’t often find this approach used in a Signal news story. Too many journalists these days use it as a crutch, basically allowing sources to shoot opinions from the bushes without attaching their names to them — and without really adding informational value to a story.
But in this case, I think it is warranted. There is a great deal of fear — political fear, job fear, and more — among people who have dealt with this issue over the past couple of years. This includes journalists, activists, public officials and, believe it or not, some members of the city staff who don’t speak out publicly because they know what’s good for them.
This source has been reliable in the past. Still, at the time, I chalked it up as something yet to be proven, so I chose to withhold the tip from my writings on the issue. It was no surprise, though, that the city held a press conference on Thursday announcing the recommendation that negotiations continue with none other than Blue Barrel, Consolidated and Burrtec.
Here are a few interesting facts:
n The proposals were released to the public May 22.
n My source predicted the staff recommendation on June 2.
n The city consultant’s report, cited as the basis for the staff recommendation, is dated June 16.
n The decision predicted three weeks ago was announced on Thursday.
Hmm... A reasonable person might ask, “Was it preordained a full two weeks before the consultant’s report came in?”
It didn’t really sink in until I was pondering it Friday night.
Once more, for clarity: I was told, three weeks ago, by a source within City Hall, that the city staff had already decided to narrow it down to those three haulers, well before the consultant’s report was completed.
That happened. Hand me a stack of Bibles and I’ll swear to it.
Something smells fishy at City Hall. And it’s not the recycling bin.
The decision is curious to say the least. The staff recommendation calls for the elimination of one hauler — BFI — who offers not only a coveted piece of property in Elsmere Canyon as an enticement, but also has agreed to the most important terms of the RFP when it comes to commercial and residential waste reduction.
I’m not saying Elsmere should be a major factor. But the question should be discussed at the council level, rather than simply being dismissed by staff and consultants behind closed doors.
Ironically, even though Blue Barrel and BFI are at the center of most of the political debate, I think perhaps Burrtec could be the one most deserving of the contract. That would throw a wrench into the political works in town, but it might be the best outcome for the taxpayers, which is, of course, supposed to be the goal here.
Don’t expect it to happen. My theory, admittedly unproven: Burrtec is window dressing, and is only in the staff’s “final three” so the city can say someone other than the existing haulers received serious consideration.
It’s true that Blue Barrel submitted by far the lowest-priced proposal. Yet, if you read the fine print, you’ll see that Blue Barrel’s proposal is essentially non-compliant with the RFP.
It’s a corked bid.
Blue Barrel — a subsidiary of Waste Management Inc. — goes so far as to say the city’s recycling demands simply can’t be met.
No other hauler balked like that.
Blue Barrel’s low bid, therefore, is based on the anticipation that the diversion goals are out the window, while the other five haulers’ bids are based on what it would cost to meet those goals.
So, basically, Blue Barrel is bidding on one project and the other haulers are bidding on a completely different one — the one the city asked for.
It’s like having a construction project to build a shopping center. You ask several contractors to bid on the job, and the lowest bidder says, “Here’s our price. It’s the best price. We’re the low bidder. But we’re going to build condos instead.”
How can you fairly compare that bidder to the others?
The city’s trash consultant takes a stab at it in the report, pointing out the very considerable differences between the RFP and Blue Barrel’s bid.
Yet, despite those differences, the recommendation is to toss out two bidders, BFI and Crown, who were in the hunt in terms of price and did a better job of complying with the RFP.
The city has yet to obtain a proposal from Blue Barrel that stacks up to the others on an apples-to-apples basis, yet the city staff is willing to toss out three of them out of hand. This, despite the obvious fact that the rates are based on widely differing levels of commitment to meeting the criteria in the RFP.
What could possibly motivate the city to do that?
As I see it, only one hauler should be dismissed at this point: E.J. Harrison, which is the only one whose prices are way out of the ballpark. They’re not even close. All five of the other haulers’ proposals should receive serious consideration, including Blue Barrel’s.
But Blue Barrel shouldn’t get a leg up on ANY of the competition until it submits a proposal to perform the same service as the other haulers — and that includes hitting the diversion goals, which it has failed to do under the current contract, at a higher price.
Unless Blue Barrel submits a proposal that complies to the same RFP terms as the other haulers, the city would be irresponsible — and, quite possibly, inviting a nasty lawsuit — if it were to sign Blue Barrel to the deal.
When the staff recommendation goes before the City Council on Tuesday, the council can make only one responsible decision: Reject the recommendation and conduct its own thorough, public review of the proposals before narrowing the field.
I’ve said all along, ever since this newspaper exposed the problems in the trash rates and diversion numbers two years ago, that the city should hire the lowest responsible bidder regardless of politics. The key factors should be price, service and the prospects for waste diversion, and the proposals should be judged in their entirety.
Until all of the bidders are bidding on the same thing, that determination can’t be made.
Now, it’s up to the council to do what the staff, for some reason, won’t.
We’re counting, specifically, on council members Cameron Smyth, Bob Kellar and Laurene Weste to un-tilt the playing field.
The other two council members — Frank Ferry and Marsha McLean — are essentially part of a mutual support society with Blue Barrel/WMI, so it would be nothing short of a miracle if they were to do anything counter to WMI’s purposes.
So it’s up to Smyth, Kellar and Weste.
I guess it would be too much to ask for the council to publicly question the motivations that led to this staff recommendation. How gutsy would that be? Alas, I don’t think a single one of them has the intestinal fortitude to go down that road. Too bad, because it could be illuminating.
I also don’t think everyone connected to the situation is dirty — in fact, I have reason to believe there are those involved who are only quietly following orders.
The odor, though, is inescapable.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
