Three of the six companies vying for the city’s lucrative trash contracts were eliminated from further negotiations Tuesday.
The City Council voted unanimously to endorse a staff recommendation to keep only Blue Barrel Disposal, Burrtec Waste Industries and Consolidated Disposal Services in the running for the city’s trash franchises. Browning Ferris Industries, Crown Disposal Co., and E.J. Harrison & Sons will not be considered in the final negotiation process.
Tom Ybarra, sales manager for Crown Disposal, said he was disappointed to see his company weeded out.
“Our proposal was based on meeting the city’s diversion requirements,” Ybarra said. “If we were one of the haulers that were selected to go on, we could have highlighted why our rates were higher — because of the city’s diversion goals.
“We are very disappointed that staff has elected a company to be part of the final negotiations that has proven they’re not able to meet the diversion requirements and has openly stated so to the city,” he said, referring to Blue Barrel.
Jill Fosselman, assistant to City Manager Ken Pulskamp, said the determining factor in selecting Blue Barrel, Burrtec and Consolidated was cost. The three haulers proposed the lowest rates for both the residential and commercial contracts, reducing current prices by 11 to 23 percent, based on first-year rates.
BFI District Manager Greg Loughnane said the city shouldn’t base its decision on cost alone.
“BFI requests that the city should address the issues before eliminating bidders,” Loughnane said.
Fosselman said the reduced playing field will provide more of an incentive for the remaining haulers to remove their “exceptions” — requested variances from the city’s goals that were outlined when the franchises were put to bid. Burrtec was the only hauler to make no exceptions to the city’s requests.
“The staff believes that, based on a recommendation from our consultant, that the evaluation phase is the best time for reviewing exceptions,” Fosselman said.
She said the city was most interested in clarifying Blue Barrel’s exceptions. In its proposal to the city, Blue Barrel said it couldn’t meet the city’s demands to divert 50 percent of trash from landfills as mandated by state law, saying the request is “unworkable and may even be impossible to meet.”
Fosselman said the city is under “no obligation to accept any of the (proposed) exceptions.”
Councilwoman Marsha McLean said she wanted to see the companies guarantee “with no exceptions that this city is going to meet the 50-percent requirement.”
Councilwoman Laurene Weste voted in favor of the staff recommendation, despite saying she was concerned about the exceptions in some of the proposals.
“Did everybody bid with the same list of things?” she asked. “We’re not comparing apples to apples. I want to be sure not to exclude anyone who would get us to our diversion numbers.
“It would be prudent to spend a week or two to get exceptions gone, and to get everyone on the same page, and then negotiate and get our final three haulers,” Weste said. “I don’t think we’re done.”
Mayor Cameron Smyth said he voted in favor of narrowing down the field because of the consultant’s recommendation.
“I was on the committee that hired our consultant,” he said. “I don’t know why now we should not listen to him anymore.”
The city’s consultant, Laith Ezzet of Hilton Farnkopf and Hobson — the same firm whose mid-1990s study was used to set residential trash rates and which was later found by The Signal to have overstated haulers’ dumping fees — said the three haulers are not being thrown out altogether, and that they can be brought back to the table if negotiations with the remaining haulers fail.
Several members of the San Fernando Valley-based North Valley Coalition, which opposes the expansion of BFI’s Sunshine Canyon Landfill in Granada Hills, urged the city to drop BFI from further consideration.
“BFI, you don’t deserve to be called a dump,” said Cathern Thompson, wearing a “No Sunshine Canyon” T-shirt.
Coalition President Wayde Hunter asked the council not to consider BFI, and to exclude Sunshine Canyon as a landfill area for the city’s hauled trash.
“We wish to thank you in advance for not dumping on us,” he said.
However, none of the residents asked the council to eliminate Burrtec — which, according to the city’s consultant, has received the green light to dump Santa Clarita’s trash in Sunshine Canyon if it wins the city contract.
Michael Arreguin, Burrtec’s vice president of municipal services, said the San Fernando Valley residents made obvious what they wanted.
“After last night,” Arreguin said Wednesday, “it’s clear that Sunshine is out of the question.”
Burrtec intends to build a materials recovery facility, or MRF, in Santa Clarita, and it also has guaranteed landfill capacity in Orange County “as a backup plan,” Arreguin said.
Santa Clarita resident Gina Brockamp said she was concerned why the city was not focusing more on recycling than cost.
“There are two companies on this list of three that can’t meet the diversion requirements,” she said. “I don’t understand why it has all come down to price, and why we’re not stressing companies that can meet the (diversion) numbers.”
Fosselman said the bidding process was not solely about price.
“This was about coming up with the best overall value,” she said.
Blue Barrel offered the city a “Do It Now” proposal, through which it would cut trash rates as early as January 2004 — almost two years ahead of schedule — if it is awarded both the residential and commercial contracts.
Resident Jami Kennedy told the council to “do it now.”
“Let’s just tell Blue Barrel, ‘You’ve got it,’ and move forward,” she said.
