ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Can the county ever shut Newhall Library?

Mercy, mercy, mercy. We’ve been at the mercy of state and local lawmakers who’ve been making tough decisions about just how heavily they’ll drop their respective budget axes on us this year. Will we still have parks? Will we still have libraries? Anticipating more and more bad news, we’ve despaired over our helplessness to do anything about it, and on those rare occasions when we’ve learned we’d be able to keep something we’ve already got, we’ve rejoiced.

Such was the case Monday when the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors adopted a plan to stave off the threatened closure of the Newhall Library and 14 other libraries around the county. Pennies from heaven were found in two county kitties that were shifted to cover a $7.3 million shortfall in the library system’s $88 million budget.

Although the situation could change this fall after the state budget dust settles, for now it appears the county won’t even have to trim any library hours this year.

But this is a one-time reprieve. The funding shift won’t be recurring, and barring any dramatic improvement in the state’s fiscal condition, we’ll probably have this same discussion next year.

Local library supporters are interested in finding a long-term funding solution, because nobody wants to be in this predicament again.

And guess what? The taxpaying residents of the city of Santa Clarita might not have to be.

There’s a possibility the city of Santa Clarita’s three county libraries can’t be shut down — not without a court fight, anyway — for reasons I’ll try to explain here.

Santa Clarita Valley residents pay an extra library tax that people in most cities within Los Angeles County don’t pay, and we have certain legal rights to enhanced library services and hours.

The story begins in 1993, when the state’s “tax grab” took $31 million from the Los Angeles County Public Library system. The Board of Supervisors responded by creating a special tax district to (partially) compensate for the loss.

The tax district imposed a new fee of $22 per year, per household. But the supervisors, on their own authority, could implement it only in the unincorporated county territories.

Taxing residents of incorporated cities required city council approval. Santa Clarita was one of only 11 cities inside Los Angeles County whose council voted for its residents to be included in the special library tax district.

Then, in November 1996, California voters approved Proposition 218. Among other things it voided all special tax districts that had been created without a direct vote of the people.

The county had to go back to the drawing board. Not only was its library tax district to be thrown out; so, too, was its fire tax district.

The supervisors placed new library and fire tax measures on the June 1997 ballot for voter approval. They passed with the needed two-thirds majority.

But like the old library tax district, the new library tax was levied only in the portion of the county that had previously participated. Only property owners in the unincorporated territories and the same 11 cities, including Santa Clarita, were asked to vote on the tax, and they’re the only ones who pay this supplemental tax today.

There are 88 cities in Los Angeles County now, and 51 are part of the Los Angeles County Public Library system.

By voting to tax themselves, residents in 11 of those cities, including ours, pay more for county library services than do the residents of 40 other cities.

Just what are the residents of those 11 cities and the unincorporated territories supposed to get for their money? The answer lies in the relevant legal documents — the supervisors’ authorizing resolution and the ballot measure language:

“To avoid major cutbacks in service hours, book purchases and children’s programs,” the former tax district is “replaced by a special tax at the same $22 annual rate to property owners, dedicated exclusively to fund library services within the areas which are subject to the special tax.”

Again, “To avoid major cutbacks in service hours.”

It doesn’t take a Johnny Cochran to argue that shutting a library would constitute a major cutback in service hours.

Can the county treat library services inside and outside the special tax area the same? No, says County Librarian Margaret Todd.

“What we’ve promised are enhanced services,” Todd said Thursday. “My interpretation is, we’re giving a specific benefit to the city (of Santa Clarita) by providing three libraries. Most cities have one.”

Noting that the documents supporting the supplemental tax “never said there would never be cuts,” Todd said she has nonetheless asked the county’s legal staff for an analysis of just what the county’s specific additional obligations are to the payers of the additional tax.

The county’s legal opinion isn’t in yet.

No doubt a good public-interest attorney acting on behalf of the “super-taxpayers” would argue that library closures should happen outside the special tax area before they happen inside it.

And can they happen inside it at all without a repeal of the special tax? That’s for the lawyers to figure out.

Of the 15 libraries that had been slated for closure, nine would have been inside the special tax area.

Shut-downs were planned only in cities with more than one library, spokeswoman Nancy Mahr said.

In recognition of the requirement for some sort of enhanced services, had Newhall been closed, Mahr said, hours at Valencia and Canyon Country (and other libraries inside the special tax area) wouldn’t have been slashed as deeply as the hours at remaining libraries outside the tax area.

“One element of our curtailment plan would have been to have more hours assigned to the other libraries (in Santa Clarita),” she said.

Now, if you’re one of those rare individuals who examines his property tax bill under a microscope, you’ll notice that your supplemental library tax is no longer $22. It had a built-in adjustment for inflation. This year you’re paying $23.79. On Monday the supervisors voted to raise it to $24.76.

The vote was 4-0, or 4-1, depending on how you count an abstention. All the supervisors voted yes except our own Michael D. Antonovich, who abstained.

Antonovich deputy Angela Mazzie said the supervisor felt “there were proposals in our district that called for closures,” so “how do you justify an increase?”

Leon Worden is The Signal’s City Editor. His column normally appears Wednesdays. “Legal Forum” by Anthony D. Zinnanti will return next week.

← Back to 2003

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-vs:2727.
System
ViewStory pages (/News/ViewStory.asp)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,075 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
viewstory:font_body
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies (1)

Host
the-signal.com
http://the-signal.com:80/News/ViewStory.asp?storyID=2801
Captured4 September 2003, 22:34:45 UTC
CaptureThe archive does not serve this capture as a facsimile; the text is extracted from it.
SHA-256f9b3d17c20ef9de9f69477dfcfd7c49a3c1aedcc5c59d0091fbe18106a37d3c7SHA-256 of the bytes the archive holds, recorded at intake. A SHA-1 of the same bytes, taken at the same time, equals the Wayback Machine’s own digest for this capture: 2PUIIL2DINWU7RJB2O5ARPMEXJFRHEHP.
Holds alone
nothing: identical text, held under another of the paper's numbering systems (record ts-vs:2801)

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [City Editor]
  • text:valley_names [4 distinct/12 mentions: Santa Clarita, Valencia, Newhall, Canyon Country]
  • text:valley_elected_official “Antonovich”
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 7, national 0