What began as a handshake agreement between two superintendents has created a rift between members of two school boards over money and bus storage.
For the past 13 years, the Newhall School District has been paying the William S. Hart Union High School District approximately $16,000 for the use of the Hart district’s transit storage yard.
The rental amount derived from an unwritten agreement between then-Hart district Superintendent H. Clyde Smyth and then-Newhall Superintendent J. Michael McGrath when the two believed it would be cost-effective to share the expense of the facility.
Several years later, Hart officials thought the rental agreement should be formalized and re-examined. After several rounds of negotiations with the Newhall district, the charge increased almost tenfold, to $150,000.
Newhall board members concede that they must increase their payment for the storage facility, but they were taken aback by the amount of the increase.
“The two districts have been together for a long time and we’ve saved a lot of money being together,” said Newhall Superintendent Marc Winger. “There are some language problems (with the contract) that we need to work out, and board members have a very different view of the premise.”
Hart board member Dennis King said the Newhall district was getting a bargain all these years and should actually pay more than the recommended $150,000 for the storage space.
“By sharing the space, it is just a slight savings to Hart but a huge savings for Newhall,” he said. “We’re not a charitable organization. We don’t build facilities for other agencies to use.”
Newhall board member Steve Tannehill said both districts are in the business of servicing the same children, and he is surprised the Hart district would ask for such a huge increase in rental fees during a budget crisis. He would like to see the rent reduced — not increased.
“It isn’t the cost per se,” Tannehill said. “There seems to exist a differing of the history of the project.”
“We should pay whatever it costs to be there, and that is the deal that has been in place for many years. We think it’s a win-win for both districts,” he said.
Tannehill said it would be a loss to both districts if they went their separate ways, causing both to pay for separate transportation costs and storage.
“There are good people on both boards serving the same families with the same motivations,” he said. “I am confident, when we sit down together, we will be able to work this out to everybody’s mutual satisfaction.”
King said it doesn’t seem right, with all the cutbacks in educational programs, for the Hart district to subsidize Newhall’s transportation costs.
“This is a perfect example of why we should be unified,” he said.
The Newhall and Hart districts’ superintendents and board members will meet with a mediator in the next couple of weeks to try to finalize a new cost-sharing agreement, officials said.
