“Santa Clarita: Safest in the Nation! Santa Clarita is Number One According to FBI.”
That was the headline on a press release from City Hall late last week.
The casual reader would likely conclude that (a) some study determined Santa Clarita has a really low crime rate in comparison to other cities; and (b) the FBI said so.
You’ll have to pardon this outburst of righteous indignation on my part, but, well, we didn’t run it in the paper because the headline isn’t true and the information in the press release is misleading.
The FBI said no such thing, and nobody in any official capacity measured Santa Clarita’s crime rate against that of other cities.
So why did the city say it?
Because the folks at City Hall get all atwitter whenever the FBI releases new crime figures. The more Santa Clarita grows, the farther down we move on the FBI’s crime list — which does not measure crime rates — and “official Santa Clarita” fears the public will get the idea that we’re not a safe place anymore.
We are a safe place, and in a moment I’ll tell you exactly how safe we are in comparison to other cities across the United States — no thanks to any numbers from City Hall.
First, I need to explain what it is the FBI reports.
The FBI reports the raw number of serious crimes for cities with populations of 100,000 and more.
Period.
It doesn’t analyze anything. It doesn’t compare one city to another or say how “safe” it is. And it doesn’t publish crime rates for those cities.
It merely reports the raw number of crimes for cities with 100,000 or more residents.
Obviously, if you’re a city like Santa Clarita, with a population close to the low end of the scale (just over 100,000), you’re going to have fewer crimes than a big city at the high end like Los Angeles.
Last year, Santa Clarita had 3,195 murders, forcible rapes, robberies, aggravated assaults, burglaries, larceny and auto thefts. Los Angeles had 190,992.
What does that tell you? Absolutely nothing. Santa Clarita had 162,900 residents at year-end. Los Angeles had 3,864,400. Of course Los Angeles had more crimes.
This hasn’t been a problem for the spin-meisters at City Hall who’ve had an easy time touting our position on the FBI list all these years. Ever since the 1990 Census showed we had a population of 110,690, the city hasn’t had to explain anything. Few other cities had just a hair over 100,000 residents, so we’ve always been at the low end of the FBI’s scale of raw number of crimes.
Now that we and all other cities in California are growing, we’re sliding down that list — for one reason only. As time goes on, more cities are added to the list as they pass the 100,000 population threshold — like Daly City and Burbank, which didn’t have 100,000 residents until 1997 and 2000, respectively, and thus weren’t previously reported by the FBI.
We will never be No. 3 or 4 or even 5 or 6 again on the FBI’s list. We now have a population of 162,900 (as of year end) and more cities are hitting 100,000. In fact, thanks to the FBI’s first-time addition of places like Burbank and Livonia, Mich., which only recently crossed the 100,000-resident rubicon, we now have the eighth-lowest number of reported violent crimes.
You might remember the media, including The Signal, reporting a couple of weeks ago that Santa Clarita was No. 8 on the FBI’s newest list.
What was the city’s response? Fearing the public might erroneously believe Santa Clarita was only the eighth “safest” city in the nation — after nurturing the bogus notion that we were third or fourth or fifth or sixth safest in the past — they went into a panic.
After all those years of feeding a faulty interpretation of the FBI numbers to the public, evidently they decided it was too difficult to explain to people that the bigger your population, the more crimes you’re going to have.
So, they spun the numbers. We were No. 8 on the FBI’s list of cities with a population over 100,000, so a city staff member took that list, lopped off the lower seven and pronounced Santa Clarita No. 1 in a magical new “population category”: cities over 150,000 population.
And that’s true. It is.
It’s also true that San Jose is the safest city in the nation with a population over 800,000, and New York is the safest city with a population over 8 million.
So what? It doesn’t say how safe Santa Clarita, San Jose or New York are in comparison to other cities.
There is no way to know anything from the raw number of crimes only.
To find out who’s “safest,” you have to compare something.
To compare something, you have to have two sides to an equation.
To calculate velocity, for instance, you have to measure miles per hour. Not just miles. Somebody isn’t “faster” just because he traveled 100 miles, if it took him longer than the guy who traveled 150 miles.
That’s what the city does when it says we’re No. 1 or No. 3 or No. 8 “safest” compared to other cities, based solely on the FBI’s list.
To compare how much crime there is in one city versus another, you must measure the crime rate. How many crimes were reported per 1,000 residents?
And this is what’s really ironic about the city’s number-fumbling:
The city is actually safer than the folks at City Hall know it to be.
Our crime rate, based on the FBI’s June 16 report of violent crimes and the state’s Jan. 1 population estimate for Santa Clarita, is 1.96 percent.
What does that mean?
Well, all things being equal, if you’re a resident of the city of Santa Clarita, you have about a 1 in 50 chance of being a victim of murder, forcible rape, robbery, aggravated assault, burglary, larceny or auto theft this year.
Now, I promised to tell you how we stack up against other cities.
We aren’t No. 1 on any federal listing, but we haven’t slipped to eighth “safest,” either.
Based on crime rates — reported violent crimes (excluding arson, because not all cities report it the same), divided by population, among the 240 or so cities with 100,000 or more residents:
Santa Clarita is the safest big city in Los Angeles County, fourth safest in California and fifth safest in the nation.
Always has been.
Leon Worden is The Signal’s city editor. His commentary appears Wednesdays.
